Eligibility for Randomized Trials of Treatments Specifically for Intracerebral Hemorrhage

Abstract

Background and Purpose— Acute treatments specifically for intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH) are being sought in randomized controlled trials. The treatment effect sizes in ongoing and future trials are likely to be small, necessitating large sample sizes. Methods— We searched online trial registries for randomized controlled trials investigating an acute treatment for ICH. For the trials whose eligibility criteria could be assessed in a prospective, community-based ICH cohort study (2010–2011), we quantified the proportions of patients who were eligible and investigated influences on these proportions. Results— We applied the eligibility criteria of 17 trials to 166 adults with ICH, of whom between 0.6% (95% confidence interval, 0.1–3.3) to 40% (95% confidence interval, 33–48) were eligible for each trial. Fewer patients were eligible for trials restricted to patients randomized within 12 hours of ICH onset (versus trials with a longer time window; P =0.03) and trials restricting eligibility according to premorbid disability (versus trials without this restriction; P =0.046). Each additional eligibility criterion reduced the portion of eligible patients by 1.3% (95% confidence interval, 0.4–2.2; adjusted R 2 =0.47; P =0.004). Conclusions— Less than half of patients with ICH were eligible for current randomized controlled trials. Future trials could maximize enrollment by minimizing the number of eligibility criteria, maximizing the time window for recruiting patients after ICH onset, permitting premorbid disability, and using a simulator to assess the impact of other eligibility critiera ( www.dcn.ed.ac.uk/ICHsimulator/ ).