Author:
Willems J L,Arnaud P,van Bemmel J H,Bourdillon P J,Brohet C,Dalla Volta S,Andersen J D,Degani R,Denis B,Demeester M
Abstract
To allow an exchange of measurements and criteria between different electrocardiographic (ECG) computer programs, an international cooperative project has been initiated aimed at standardization of computer-derived ECG measurements. To this end an ECG reference library of 250 ECGs with selected abnormalities was established and a comprehensive reviewing scheme was devised for the visual determination of the onsets and offsets of P, QRS, and T waves. This task was performed by a group of cardiologists on highly amplified, selected complexes from the library of ECGs. With use of a modified Delphi approach, individual outlying point estimates were eliminated in four successive rounds. In this way final referee estimates were obtained that proved to be highly reproducible and precise. This reference data base was used to study measurement results obtained with nine vectorcardiographic and 10 standard 12-lead ECG analysis programs. The medians of program determinations of P, QRS, and T wave onsets and offsets were close to the final referee estimates. However, an important variability could be demonstrated between measurements from individual programs and mean differences from the referee estimates amounted to 10 msec for QRS for certain programs. In addition, the variances of all programs with respect to the referee point estimates were variable. Some programs proved to be more accurate and stable when the data from high- vs low-noise recordings were analyzed. Average Q wave durations calculated from ECGs for which programs agreed on the presence of a Q or QS wave differed by more than 8 msec in several program-to-program comparisons. Such differences may have important consequences with respect to diagnostic performance. Various factors that might explain these differences have been determined. The present study demonstrates that to allow an exchange of results and diagnostic criteria between different ECG computer programs, definitions, minimum wave requirements, and measurement procedures urgently need to be standardized.
Publisher
Ovid Technologies (Wolters Kluwer Health)
Subject
Physiology (medical),Cardiology and Cardiovascular Medicine
Reference29 articles.
1. Pipberger HV: Twenty years of ECG data processing. What has been accomplished? In Antaloczy Z editor: Modem electrocardiology. Amsterdam 1978 Excerpta Medica p 159
2. Rautaharju PM: The current state of computer ECG analysis: a critique. In van Bemmel JH Willems JL editors: Trends in computer-processed electrocardiograms. Amsterdam 1977 North Holland Publishing Co p 117
3. Drazen E: Use of computer-assisted ECG interpretation in the United States. In Ripley KL Ostrow HG editors: Computers in cardiology. Long Beach CA 1979 IEEE Computer Society p 83
4. Willems JL Pardaens J: Differences in measurement results obtained by four different ECG computer programs. In Ostrow HG Ripley KL editors: Computers in cardiology. Long Beach CA 1977 IEEE Computer Society p 115
5. A plea for common standards in computer aided ECG analysis
Cited by
105 articles.
订阅此论文施引文献
订阅此论文施引文献,注册后可以免费订阅5篇论文的施引文献,订阅后可以查看论文全部施引文献