Comparison of micro skin grafting and transplantation of non-cultured melanocyte keratinocyte suspension for the treatment of stable vitiligo: A pilot study

Abstract

Objectives: We conducted this pilot study to compare the outcomes of non-cultured epidermal suspension (NCES) with that of micro skin grafting (MSG) in the treatment of stable vitiligo Material and Methods: Twenty-nine patients with clinically stable vitiligo lesions (defined as the occurrence of no new lesions and no increase in the size of preexisting lesions for the past six months) and age group between 12 and 70 years were enrolled in the study. The enrolled patients were randomized into two groups using simple randomization using computer-generated random numbers, and allocation concealment was done using opaque sealed envelopes. Group 1 was comprised of 15 patients with 23 stable vitiligo lesions, and group 2 comprised of 14 patients with 22 stable vitiligo lesions. Patients in group 1 were transplanted with non-cultured melanocytes and keratinocytes. Patients in group 2 were treated using micro skin grafts after obtaining written informed consent. Ethical clearance was obtained from the Institute ethics committee, and the principles of the 1975 Declaration of Helsinki were followed. Results: At the end of four months post-treatment, two patients (one in each group) did not follow up after removal of dressing at the first week. Results were analyzed at four months in 27 patients – 14 patients with 22 lesions in group 1 and 13 patients with 21 lesions in group 2. Repigmentation at 16 weeks post-surgery was evaluated. Excellent repigmentation (>90%) was seen in 45.45% of lesions in the non-cultured epidermal suspension (NCES) group as compared to 38.09% of lesions in the micro skin grafting (MSG) group, and this difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.7597). Repigmentation > 75% was achieved in 54.54% of lesions in the non-cultured epidermal suspension (NCES) group compared to 38.09% of lesions in the micro skin grafting (MSG) group, and this difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.3640). Both the groups did not have any significant complications like scarring, milia, or any cobble stoning at the donor site. The recipient area had resistance to the spread of pigment at the margins of lesions. Six lesions in both the groups with excellent response, 3 in each group had achromic fissure or hypopigmented halos at the margins of lesions. Conclusion: Both non-cultured epidermal suspension (NCES) and micro skin grafting (MSG) have been found to be safe and effective modalities with comparable efficacy in the surgical treatment of stable vitiligo. However, future trials on large sample sizes are warranted to validate our results.