Earlier appearance of Risser sign on ultrasound versus radiograph in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis

Abstract

Objective The usefulness of ultrasound in the detailed assessment of the Risser sign is still unclear. The purpose of this study was to analyze the usefulness of ultrasound for determining the Risser sign compared with that determined by conventional radiography by each Risser grade. Materials and Methods Eighty-eight iliac crests from 44 adolescent patients who visited the scoliosis clinic with Risser grades 0-4 were evaluated. The ultrasound probe was placed vertically on the iliac crest and the point where iliac apophysis ossification ended was marked. The length of ossification relative to the length of the iliac crest was calculated. Results Agreement between radiographic and ultrasound images were found in 58/86 iliac crests (67%). Kappa value was 0.565. Agreement between the two methods with regard to Risser grade was 53% for grade 0, 43% for grade 1, 47% for grade 2, 88% for grade 3, and 90% for grade 4. With additional analysis by integrating grades into two groups, the agreement rate was 47.7% and the Kappa value was 0.288 in the grade 0-2 group, and 88% and 0.703 in grades 3-4 group, respectively. In cases of disagreements, 93% of the iliac crests were judged as having higher Risser grades by ultrasound than by radiograph. Conclusion Risser sign evaluation by ultrasound demonstrated a higher agreement rate in grades 3 and 4, whereas less agreement was found in grades 0-2. In the majority of cases with disagreement, ultrasound showed a higher grade than radiography, suggesting that ossification can be detected earlier with ultrasound than with radiography.