Characterization and sequence analyses of antibody-selected antigenic variants of herpes simplex virus show a conformationally complex epitope on glycoprotein H

Abstract

Thirteen antigenic variants of herpes simplex virus which were resistant to neutralization by monoclonal antibody 52S or LP11 were isolated and characterized. The antibodies in the absence of complement potently neutralize infectivity of wild-type virus as well as inhibit the transfer of virus from infected to uninfected cells ("plaque inhibition") and decrease virus-induced cell fusion by syncytial strains. The first variant isolated arose in vivo. Of 66 type 1 isolates analyzed from typing studies of 100 clinical isolates, one was identified as resistant to neutralization by LP11 antibody. The glycoprotein H (gH) sequence was derived and compared with those of wild-type and syncytial laboratory strains SC16, strain 17, and HFEM. The sequences were highly conserved in contrast to the diversity observed between gH sequences from herpesviruses of different subgroups. Only four coding changes were present in any of the comparisons, and only one unique coding change was observed between the laboratory strains and the clinical isolate (Asp-168 to Gly). These sequences were compared with those of antigenic variants selected by antibody in tissue culture. Twelve variants were independently selected with antibody LP11 or 52S from parent strain SC16 or HFEM. For each variant, the gH nucleotide sequence was derived and a point mutation was identified giving rise to a single amino acid substitution. The LP11-resistant viruses encoded gH sequences with amino acid substitutions at sites distributed over one-half of the gH external domain, Glu-86, Asp-168, or Arg-329, while the 52S-resistant mutant viruses had substitutions at adjacent positions Ser-536 and Ala-537. One LP11 mutant virus had a point mutation in the gH gene that was identical to that of the clinical isolate, giving rise to a substitution of Asp-168 with Gly. Both LP11 and 52S appeared to recognize distinct gH epitopes as mutant virus resistant to neutralization and immunoprecipitation with LP11 remained sensitive to 52S and the converse was shown for the 52S-resistant mutant virus. This is consistent with previous studies which showed that while the 52S epitope could be formed in the absence of other virus products, virus gene expression was required for stable presentation of the LP11 epitope, and for transport of gH to the cell surface (Gompels and Minson, J. Virol. 63:4744-4755, 1989). All mutant viruses produced numbers of infectious particles that were similar to those produced by the wild-type virus, with the exception of one variant which produced lower yields.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)