Suppression of Reactive Oxygen Species Accumulation Accounts for Paradoxical Bacterial Survival at High Quinolone Concentration

Abstract

ABSTRACT When bacterial cells are exposed to increasing concentrations of quinolone-class antibacterials, survival drops, reaches a minimum, and then recovers, sometimes to 100%. Despite decades of study, events underlying this paradoxical high-concentration survival remain obscure. Since reactive oxygen species (ROS) have been implicated in antimicrobial lethality, conditions generating paradoxical survival were examined for diminished ROS accumulation. Escherichia coli cultures were treated with various concentrations of nalidixic acid, followed by measurements of survival, rate of protein synthesis, and ROS accumulation. The last measurement used a dye (carboxy-H2DCFDA) that fluoresces in the presence of ROS; fluorescence was assessed by microscopy (individual cells) and flow cytometry (batch cultures). High, nonlethal concentrations of nalidixic acid induced lower levels of ROS than moderate, lethal concentrations. Sublethal doses of exogenous hydrogen peroxide became lethal and eliminated the nalidixic acid-associated paradoxical survival. Thus, quinolone-mediated lesions needed for ROS-executed killing persist at high, nonlethal quinolone concentrations, thereby implicating ROS as a key factor in cell death. Chloramphenicol suppressed nalidixic acid-induced ROS accumulation and blocked lethality, further supporting a role for ROS in killing. Nalidixic acid also inhibited protein synthesis, with extensive inhibition at high concentrations correlating with lower ROS accumulation and paradoxical survival. A catalase deficiency, which elevated ROS levels, overcame the inhibitory effect of chloramphenicol on nalidixic acid-mediated killing, emphasizing the importance of ROS. The data collectively indicate that ROS play a dominant role in the lethal action of narrow-spectrum quinolone-class compounds; a drop in ROS levels accounted for the quinolone tolerance observed at very high concentrations.