A novel hybridization capture method for direct whole genome sequencing of clinical specimens to inform Legionnaires’ disease investigations

Abstract

ABSTRACT The unprecedented precision and resolution of whole genome sequencing (WGS) can provide definitive identification of infectious agents for epidemiological outbreak tracking. WGS approaches, however, are frequently impeded by low pathogen DNA recovery from available primary specimens or unculturable samples. A cost-effective hybrid capture assay for Legionella pneumophila WGS analysis directly on primary specimens was developed. DNA from a diverse range of sputum and autopsy specimens PCR-positive for L. pneumophila serogroup 1 (LPSG1) was enriched with this method, and WGS was performed. All tested specimens were determined to be enriched for Legionella reads (up to 209,000-fold), significantly improving the discriminatory power to compare relatedness when no clinical isolate was available. We found the WGS data from some enriched specimens to differ by less than five single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) when compared to the WGS data of a matched culture isolate. This testing and analysis retrospectively provided previously unconfirmed links to environmental sources for clinical specimens of sputum and autopsy lung tissue. The latter provided the additional information needed to identify the source of these culture-negative cases associated with the South Bronx 2015 Legionnaires’ disease (LD) investigation in New York City. This new method provides a proof of concept for future direct clinical specimen hybrid capture enrichment combined with WGS and bioinformatic analysis during outbreak investigations. IMPORTANCE Legionnaires’ disease (LD) is a severe and potentially fatal type of pneumonia primarily caused by inhalation of Legionella -contaminated aerosols from man-made water or cooling systems. LD remains extremely underdiagnosed as it is an uncommon form of pneumonia and relies on clinicians including it in the differential and requesting specialized testing. Additionally, it is challenging to obtain clinical lower respiratory specimens from cases with LD, and when available, culture requires specialized media and growth conditions, which are not available in all microbiology laboratories. In the current study, a method for Legionella pneumophila using hybrid capture by RNA baiting was developed, which allowed us to generate sufficient genome resolution from L. pneumophila serogroup 1 PCR-positive clinical specimens. This new approach offers an additional tool for surveillance of future LD outbreaks where isolation of Legionella is not possible and may help solve previously unanswered questions from past LD investigations.