Quality of commercially produced Shigella serogrouping and serotyping antisera

Abstract

Shigella grouping antisera from five manufacturers and typing antisera from two were purchased and evaluated with homologous and heterologous Shigella strains in the slide agglutination test. Only 31 of 73 (42%) antisera were satisfactory. In many instances, the antisera gave negative, as opposed to weak, reactions when they should have given strong positive reactions. Four reagents cross-reacted with Shigella strains. Of the 19 polyvalent grouping antisera to subgroups Shigella dysenteriae serotypes 1 through 7, S. flexneri serotypes 1 through 6, S. boydii serotypes 1 through 7, and S. sonnei forms I, II, only one S. sonnei reagent and five S. flexneri reagents were satisfactory with greater than or equal to 90% of the homologous strains. The reagent of poorest quality was satisfactory with only 18% of the homologous strains. There were three polyvalent antisera to the higher types of S. dysenteriae and S. boydii, which were available from only one company, that adequately identified 80, 63, and 65% of the homologous strains. Typing antisera were available from only two companies, and 30 of 51 (59%) were satisfactory. Commercially available Shigella antisera are inadequate for the laboratory testing required for planning the development of and evaluating Shigella vaccines.