Static vs. Modal Analysis of Asymmetric Buildings: Effectiveness of Dynamic Eccentricity Formulations

Abstract

The use of modal analysis appears necessary in order to reduce both displacement demand under weak seismic events and ductility demand under strong earthquakes. Static analysis can be effective only if used with proper values of additional eccentricities. To overcome the inaccuracy of the code formulations, the authors propose a simple procedure that gives the exact values of these eccentricities and discuss the influence of the main parameters that govern the structural behavior. They also point out the difficulty in evaluating some parameters (stiffness radius of gyration, structural eccentricity) in the case of multistory buildings and discuss the validity of simplified formulations proposed to overcome this problem. The effectiveness of static analysis, applied to three-dimensional multistory structures with properly evaluated corrective eccentricities, is analyzed with reference both to regularly asymmetric multistory schemes and to an actual irregularly asymmetric structure (the main building of the Faculty of Engineering at the University of Catania, Italy).