Persistence of large-scale coherent structures in a turbulent pipe flow through an improved lattice Boltzmann approach

Abstract

We simulated a turbulent pipe flow within the lattice Boltzmann method using a multiple-relaxation-time collision operator with Maxwell–Boltzmann equilibrium distribution expanded, for the sake of a more accurate description, up to the sixth order in Hermite polynomials. The moderately turbulent flow (Reτ≈181.3) is able to reproduce up to the fourth statistical moment with great accuracy compared with other numerical schemes and with experimental data. A coherent structure identification was performed based on the most energetic streamwise turbulent mode, which revealed a surprising memory effect related to the large-scale forcing scheme that triggered the pipe's turbulent state. We observe that the existence of large-scale motions that are out of the pipe's stationary regime does not affect the flow's detailed single-point statistical features. Furthermore, the transitions between the coherent structures of different topological modes were analyzed as a stochastic process. We find that for finely resolved data, the transitions are effectively Markovian, but for larger decimation time lags, due to topological mode degeneracy, non-Markovian behavior emerges, in agreement with previous experimental studies.