Limitations and generalizations of the first order kinetics reaction expression for modeling diffusion-driven exchange: Implications on NMR exchange measurements

Abstract

The study and modeling of water exchange in complex media using different applications of diffusion and relaxation magnetic resonance (MR) have been of interest in recent years. Most models attempt to describe this process using a first order kinetics expression, which is appropriate to describe chemical exchange; however, it may not be suitable to describe diffusion-driven exchange since it has no direct relationship to diffusion dynamics of water molecules. In this paper, these limitations are addressed through a more general exchange expression that does consider such important properties. This exchange fraction expression features a multi-exponential recovery at short times and a mono-exponential decay at long times, both of which are not captured by the first order kinetics expression. Furthermore, simplified exchange expressions containing partial information of the analyzed system’s diffusion and relaxation processes and geometry are proposed, which can potentially be employed in already established estimation protocols. Finally, exchange fractions estimated from simulated MR data and derived here were compared, showing qualitative similarities but quantitative differences, suggesting that the features of the derived exchange fraction in this paper can be partially recovered by employing an existing estimation framework.