Affiliation:
1. James Cook University Singapore
2. James Cook University Singapore Townsville Australia
Abstract
Abstract
The study explores the influence of relative pronouns WHO or THAT on attributions of humanness across four categories of entities (unnamed nonhuman animals, named animals, machines, and people). Eighty-three university students performed an attribution task where they saw a priming phrase containing one category item with either WHO or THAT (e.g., deer who are …) and then two trait attribute items (Uniquely Human UH/Human Nature HN word pairs; e.g., distant-nervous), from which they selected the trait attribute most meaningfully suited to the phrase. Data were analyzed with a repeated measures 2 (humanness: HN traits, UH traits) × 2 (pronoun: WHO, THAT) × 4 (category: unnamed animals, named animals, machines, people) ANOVA. Participants responded relatively faster to HN trait attributes than to UH traits, and responded faster to named animals than to all other entities. Faster responses also ensued for people-WHO pairings than people-THAT pairings, and vice versa for named animals.
Subject
Sociology and Political Science,General Veterinary
Reference31 articles.
1. The decline of the nation-state and the end of the rights of man;Arendt;The Origins of Totalitarianism,1951
2. The English lexicon project;Balota;Behavior Research Methods,2007
3. Remembering the children that are still missing [Web log message];Barrett;Blogger News Network: High-quality English language analysis and editorial writing on the news,2009
4. Experts warn of triggers that can turn kids into killers in the wake of an 11–year-old charged with murder;Brook;Lifestyle: Real Life True Stories,2016
5. Sexist language in occupational information: Does it make a difference?;Brooks;Journal of Vocational Behavior,1983