Affiliation:
1. Department of Political Science and International Studies, Bahir Dar University, Bahir Dar, Ethiopia, belayneh3415@gmail.com
2. Sant’ Anna School of Advanced Studies, Pisa, Italy, andebethailu.assefa@santannapisa.it
Abstract
Abstract
This article approaches the ethical dilemma of healthcare allocation and rationing from the perspective of pragmatist ethics, mainly following John Dewey’s ethics. The moral dilemma of healthcare allocation arises whenever we allocate limited resources, and rationing is a necessary option for distributing available resources. In a broader sense, the moral problems of healthcare allocation also encompass the issue of access to primary healthcare, especially for low-income sections of communities. In this sense, allocation always entails rationing – denying service to someone for the benefit of others. Such aspects of allocation and rationing and the relational aspect of disease and health make the problem morally controversial, which makes it difficult to agree on a principle or principles of allocation and rationing applicable across different contexts. Hence, this paper argues that moral challenges of healthcare rationing ought not to be addressed through the appeal to principles, but rather through deliberation that embraces a more pragmatic and democratic approach to negotiating health resource allocation and rationing. However, this does not mean that moral principles and values are insignificant in healthcare allocation.
Reference40 articles.
1. Principlism, Medical Individualism, and Health Promotion in Resource-Poor Countries: Can Autonomy-Based Bioethics Promote Social Justice and Population Health?;Azétsop, Jacquineau,2010
2. We Need to Talk About Rationing: The Need to Normalize Discussion About Healthcare Rationing in a Post covid-19 Era;Bhatia, Neera.,2020
3. The ‘Bantu Clinic’: A Genealogy of the African Patient;Butchart, Alexander.,1997
4. A Relational Approach to Rationing in a Time of Pandemic;Cordeiro-Rodrigues, Luís,2021
5. Liberalism and Medical Ethics;Daniels, Norman.,1992