Fertilizer response of barley silage in southern and central Alberta

Abstract

Barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) silage is the foundation for cattle production on the Canadian prairies, but few studies have evaluated fertilizer requirements for the range of cultivars, soil types and environmental conditions in which it is grown. The objectives of this study were (1) to determine optimum N fertilizer rates for a range of barley cultivars when used for silage in southern and central Alberta and (2) to determine the frequency and impact of P, K and S deficiencies. Thirty-two field experiments were conducted from 1994 to 1996; 20 in southern Alberta under irrigated (8) or dryland (12) conditions and 12 in central Alberta under dryland conditions. Two semi-dwarf (CDC Earl, Tukwa) and three conventional (AC Lacombe, Leduc and Seebe) cultivars were tested. Fertilizer treatments included six rates of N (0 to 200 kg ha-1) and one rate each of P (13 kg ha-1), K (50 kg ha-1) and S (20 or 30 kg ha-1), compared to an appropriate unfertilized control. Optimum rates of N fertilizer ranged from 0 to 172 kg N ha-1. Irrigated sites had the highest N demand but the lowest economic optimum rate of N fertilizer (NFopt) due to high fertilizer N efficiency and high soil N availability. Dryland sites in southern Alberta had a lower N demand than irrigated sites, but NFopt was higher due to lower soil N availability. Sites in central Alberta had the least demand for N, but NFopt was similar to irrigated sites due to low N fertilizer efficiency. Nitrogen fertilizer efficiency frequently exceeded 80% in southern Alberta, particularly under irrigation. Soil N uptake increased with optimum barley yield, indicating that factors that increased crop growth also increased net mineralization and/or efficiency of soil N uptake. A good fit of NFopt was obtained in southern Alberta based on spring soil NO3-N levels and optimum yield. The best estimate of NFopt in central Alberta was the mean due to the lack of a relationship between soil N uptake and spring soil NO3-N. Barley response to P fertilizer was greatest in central Alberta and least in southern Alberta under irrigation. Few responses to K or S fertilizer were observed due to the generally adequate levels of these nutrients in Alberta soils. Fiber concentrations were not strongly affected by fertilizer treatment, while protein concentrations varied with the availability of N relative to demand. Improvements in prediction of fertilizer response for barley silage require better predictors of N fertilizer efficiency and soil N uptake, particularly in central Alberta. Key words: Hordeum vulgare, nitrogen fertilizer use efficiency, protein, fiber