Remediating Ni-phytotoxicity of contaminated Quarry muck soil using limestone and hydrous iron oxide

Abstract

Remediation of excessive soil metals in situ is receiving new attention because the alternative, soil removal and replacement, is very expensive, requires disposal of the removed soil and may achieve no better environmental remediation than the in situ treatments. A factorial pot experiment was conducted with two muck soils contaminated by a Ni refinery; we tested the effectiveness of making the soil calcareous and addition of freshly precipitated hydous ferric oxide (HFO) in reducing soil Ni phytotoxicity to the Ni-sensitive crops, oat and redbeet, and a Ni-resistant crop, wheat. Fertilized but otherwise untreated soil caused significant Ni phytotoxicity to oats and redbeet, but not to wheat, on both soils. Adding limestone reduced the concentration of Ni in shoots of all species and alleviated the symptoms specific to Ni phytotoxicity in oat (banded chlorosis). The addition of HFO was more effective in reducing shoot Ni concentration in the redbeets than in crops from the Poaceae family. Both amendments induced phosphorus and/or manganese deficiency depending on the crop tested. The experiment indicates that some combination of limestone and Fe oxides can readily remediate Ni phytotoxicity of the tested soils, but that Mn and P fertilizers would be needed to achieve practical in situ remediation of Ni phytotoxicity of Quarry muck (Terric Mesisol). Key words: Nickel, soil, plant, phytotoxicity, remediation