Abstract
BackgroundGlobally, the measurement of quality is an important process that supports the provision of high-quality and safe healthcare services. The requirement for valid quality measurement to gauge improvements and monitor performance is echoed in the Australian prehospital care setting. The aim of this study was to use an evidence-informed expert consensus process to identify valid quality indicators (QIs) for Australian prehospital care provided by ambulance services.MethodsA modified RAND/UCLA appropriateness method was conducted with a panel of Australian prehospital care experts from February to May 2019. The proposed QIs stemmed from a scoping review and were systematically prepared within a clinical and non-clinical classification system, and a structure/process/outcome and access/safety/effectiveness taxonomy. Rapid reviews were performed for each QI to produce evidence summaries for consideration by the panellists. QIs were deemed valid if the median score by the panel was 7–9 without disagreement.ResultsOf 117 QIs, the expert panel rated 84 (72%) as valid. This included 26 organisational/system QIs across 7 subdomains and 58 clinical QIs within 10 subdomains.Most QIs were process indicators (n=62; 74%) while QIs describing structural elements and desired outcomes were less common (n=13; 15% and n=9; 11%, respectively). Non-exclusively, 18 (21%) QIs addressed access to healthcare, 21 (25%) described safety aspects and 64 (76%) specified elements contributing to effective services and care. QIs on general time intervals, such as response time, were not considered valid by the panel.ConclusionThis study demonstrates that with consideration of best available evidence a substantial proportion of QIs scoped and synthesised from the international literature are valid for use in the Australian prehospital care context.
Funder
Australasian College of Paramedicine
Subject
Critical Care and Intensive Care Medicine,General Medicine,Emergency Medicine
Reference25 articles.
1. Indicators to measure prehospital care quality: a scoping review;Pap;JBI Database Syst Rev Implement Rep,2018
2. Australian Government Productivity Commission - Steering Committee for the Review of Government Service Provision . Report on Government Services - Chapter 11 (Ambulance Services) [Internet]. Canberra, 2020. Available: https://www.pc.gov.au
3. Harrison L . Ambulance Services in Australia - Healthy growth: Population growth has increased demand for ambulance services [Internet]. Melbourne, 2019. Available: https://www.ibisworld.com
4. Seven propositions of the science of improvement: exploring foundations;Perla;Qual Manag Health Care,2013
5. Indicators of quality in health care;Lawrence;Eur J Gen Pract,1997