Body composition of extreme performers in the US Marine Corps

Abstract

BackgroundThe creation of highly muscled and strong fighters is a recurring theme in human performance enhancement concepts. Physical readiness standards, intended to prevent obesity in the military, produce contradictory objectives, hounding large individuals to lose weight because of confusion between body size and body composition. Through selection, specialised training and policy exceptions the US Marine Corps has successfully developed a unique group of large (body mass index (BMI) >30 kg/m2) and strong individuals, the body bearers (BB) who carry coffins of Marines to their final resting place.MethodsWe examined the relationship between adiposity and body size from nine male BB (age 25.0±2.1, height: 1.84±0.04 (1.80–1.92) m, BMI: 33.0±2.1 (30–37) kg/m2). Body composition was assessed by dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA), bioelectrical impedance (BIA) and tape measured abdominal circumference (AC)-based equations and from three-dimensional scanning (3DS).ResultsMeasures were made of fat-free mass (FFM): 90.5±7.0 (82.0–106.7) kg, where FFM included total body water: 62.8±5.0 (55.8–71.8) L, representing 69±2 (67–73) % of FFM, along with calculated FFM index: 26.8±2.4 (24.4–32.9) kg/m2). DXA measures were made for bone mineral content 4.1±0.4 (3.5–4.9) kg, bone mineral density (BMD) 1.56±0.10 (1.37–1.76) g/cm2and %BF 19.5±6.6 (9.0–27.8). Additional measures of percent body fat (%BF) were made by AC: 20.3±2.9 (15.2–24.6), BIA: 23.7±6.4 (9.8–29.2) and 3DS: 25.5±4.7 (18.9–32.2). AC %BF reasonably matched DXA %BF, with expected overprediction and underprediction at low and high DXA %BF. BIA %BF was affected by deviations from assumed FFM hydration (72%–73%).ConclusionThese men are classified as obese by BMI but carried massive amounts of muscle and bone on their large frames, while presenting a range of %BF irrelevant to strength performance. BMI did not predict obesity and adiposity had no association with muscle mass and strength performance.