Abstract
In the wake of two recent high-profile, controversial cases involving the prosecution and conviction of Drs Bramhall and Bawa-Garba, this article considers when it is socially desirable to criminalise doctors’ behaviour, exploring how the matters of harm, public wrongs and the public interest can play out to justify—or not, as the case may be—the criminal law’s intervention. Dr Bramhall branded his initials on patients’ livers during transplant surgery, behaviour acknowledged not to have caused his patients any harm by way of injury to their organs. Dr Bawa-Garba misdiagnosed and failed to properly assess a 6-year-old boy with pneumonia and sepsis under her care, who subsequently died. Taking account of contextual and public interest concerns, can and should there be exceptions to imposing criminal liability where a doctor’s behaviour is deemed grossly negligent and a significant contribution to a patient’s death? And is it really appropriate to subject a doctor to penal sanction where he may have committed a private wrong against a patient, but does not set back their interests?
Subject
Health Policy,Arts and Humanities (miscellaneous),Issues, ethics and legal aspects,Health (social science)
Reference52 articles.
1. Marsh H . The surgeon who signed his patients’ livers was silly, not criminal. The law is an ass. The Guardian, 15 December 2017; Rimmer A. Bawa-Garba case fallout: five minutes with… David Galloway. BMJ;2018:k1573.
2. Bostock N . GMC warning over calls for GPs to stop written reflection. GP 2018 http://bit.ly/2FEFDWQ.
3. Medical manslaughter: where next?;Vaughan;The Bulletin of the Royal College of Surgeons of England,2018
4. Brazier M , Ost S . Medicine and Bioethics in the Theatre of the Criminal Process. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2013.
5. Sanders A . Victims’ Interests and Criminal Justice in the Healthcare Setting. In: Griffiths D , Sanders A , eds. Medicine, Crime and Society. Cambridge: Cambridge: University Press, 2013:81–100.
Cited by
4 articles.
订阅此论文施引文献
订阅此论文施引文献,注册后可以免费订阅5篇论文的施引文献,订阅后可以查看论文全部施引文献