Abstract
BackgroundTraining programmes for obstetrics and gynaecology (O&G) and general surgery (GS) vary significantly, but both require proficiency in laparoscopic skills. We sought to determine performance in each specialty.DesignProspective, observational study.SettingHealth Education England North-West, UK.Participants47 surgical trainees (24 O&G and 23 GS) were subdivided into four groups: 11 junior O&G, 13 senior O&G, 11 junior GS and 12 senior GS trainees.ObjectivesTrainees were tested on four simulated laparoscopic tasks: laparoscopic camera navigation (LCN), hand–eye coordination (HEC), bimanual coordination (BMC) and suturing with intracorporeal knot tying (suturing).ResultsO&G trainees completed LCN (p<0.001), HEC (p<0.001) and BMC (p<0.001) significantly slower than GS trainees. Furthermore, O&G found fewer number of targets in LCN (p=0.001) and dropped a greater number of pins than the GS trainees in BMC (p=0.04). In all three tasks, there were significant differences between O&G and GS trainees but no difference between the junior and senior groups within each specialty. Performance in suturing also varied by specialty; senior O&G trainees scored significantly lower than senior GS trainees (O&G 11.4±4.4 vs GS 16.8±2.1, p=0.03). Whilst suturing scores improved with seniority among O&G trainees, there was no difference between the junior and senior GS trainees (senior O&G 11.4±4.4 vs junior O&G 3.6±2.1, p=0.004).DiscussionGS trainees performed better than O&G trainees in core laparoscopic skills, and the structure of O&G training may require modification.Trial registration numberClinicalTrials.gov Registry (NCT05116332).
Funder
Medtronic
KARL STORZ
British Society of Gynaecological Endoscopy
Reference41 articles.
1. Minimally invasive abdominal surgery: lux et veritas past, present, and future
2. Open laparoscopy: 29-year experience
3. Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists . Royal college of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, core curriculum for obstetrics and Gynaecology. 2019. Available: https://www.gmc-uk.org/-/media/documents/core-og-curriculum-2019-final-gmc-approved-20210504_pdf-79992893.pdf
4. Intercollegiate surgical curriculum program (ISCP) . Intercollegiate surgical curriculum program, core surgical training curriculum: ISCP. 2021. Available: https://www.iscp.ac.uk/media/1326/core-surgical-training-curriculum-2021-minor-changes-for-august-2022.pdf
5. Defining a structured training program for acquiring basic and advanced Laparoscopic psychomotor skills in a simulator;Molinas;Gynecol Surg,2010