Baseline data from a planned RCT on attitudes to female genital cutting after migration: when are interventions justified?

Abstract

ObjectivesTo present the primary outcomes from a baseline study on attitudes towards female genital cutting (FGC) after migration.DesignBaseline data from a planned cluster randomised, controlled trial. Face-to-face interviews were used to collect questionnaire data in 2015. Based on our hypothesis that established Somalis could be used as facilitators of change among those newly arrived, data were stratified into years of residency in Sweden.SettingSweden.Participants372 Somali men and women, 206 newly arrived (0–4 years), 166 established (>4 years).Primary outcome measuresWhether FGC is acceptable, preferred for daughter and should continue, specified on anatomical extent.ResultsThe support for anatomical change of girls and women’s genitals ranged from 0% to 2% among established and from 4% to 8% among newly arrived. Among those supporting no anatomical change, 75%–83% among established and 53%–67% among newly arrived opposed all forms of FGC, with the remaining supporting pricking of the skin with no removal of tissue. Among newly arrived, 37% stated that pricking was acceptable, 39% said they wanted their daughter to be pricked and 26% reported they wanted pricking to continue being practised. Those who had lived in Sweden ≤ 2 years had highest odds of supporting FGC; thereafter, the opposition towards FGC increased over time after migration.ConclusionA majority of Somali immigrants, including those newly arrived, opposed all forms of FGC with increased opposition over time after migration. The majority of proponents of FGC supported pricking. We argue that it would have been unethical to proceed with the intervention as it, with this baseline, would have been difficult to detect a change in attitudes given that a majority opposed all forms of FGC together with the evidence that a strong attitude change is already happening. Therefore, we decided not to implement the planned intervention.Trial registration numberTrial registration numberNCT02335697;Pre-results.