First Report of Pantoea ananatis and Pantoea eucalypti causing onion leaf blight and bulb decay in Central Chile

Abstract

Nearly 5,400 hectares of long-day onions (Allium cepa) are cultivated in the Central Zone of Chile (UTM 33°3´S to 37°24´S). During summer 2021-22 and 2022-23 (December to February), followed by high temperatures (around 35°C) and high humidity conditions, symptoms showing yellowing, soft rot, blight on old leaves, necrotic tips, and soft bulbs were observed. The affected plants were observed in "spots" into the fields, and the incidence reached 5-10%. The severity was high, and 70-80% of the affected plants died. Symptomatic plants from different fields from the Coquimbo, Metropolitan, O´Higgins and Maule regions were sampled. Isolations were made using casamino-acid peptone glucose (CPG) agar medium (Schaad, 2001). Yellow-pigmented, circular to irregular shaped colonies were observed. Molecular identification was carried out by partial 16S rRNA gene sequencing, resulting in the identification of 18 isolates of Pantoea spp. from twelve different fields. Selected strains were biochemically analyzed using the GEN III BIOLOG microtest system (Hayward, CA) and were identified as Pantoea spp. BLAST analyses of the 16S rRNA sequences (602 nt) of selected strains (GenBank Accession No. OR527817 to OR527819) against the NCBI Database resulted in the identification of Pantoea species with 100% coverage and 100% identity. To determine the Pantoea species of each strain, housekeeping gene gyrB (Delétoile et al. 2009) was amplified and sequenced (GenBank Accessions No. OR544061 to OR544063). BLAST analysis (802 nt) of selected strains resulted in 100% coverage and 100% identity, identifying three different species: P. ananatis, P. eucalypti, and P. agglomerans. Pantoea species were isolated from both leaves and bulbs and no more than one species was observed per field. Pathogenicity assays in onion plants and bulbs were performed based on the methodology described by Asselin et al. (2018). Five onion plants cv. Cimarron of thirteen-week-old were inoculated by wounding an external leave with a sterile toothpick previously immersed in a bacterial suspension at ~ 108 CFU/mL and maintained at 26-28°C for 30 days in high humidity conditions. Control plants were inoculated with sterile water. Plants inoculated with Pantoea spp. showed chlorosis, soft rot, and necrosis mainly in older leaves, as observed in the field, while negative control plants remained healthy. Pantoea spp. were re-isolated from the inoculated onion plants. Toothpicks dipped in the inoculum were stuck 4 cm into the shoulders of onion bulbs and incubated at 26°C for 20 days. Water was inoculated as a negative control. At the end of the incubation period, the bulbs were opened longitudinally across their inoculation sites and shrunken, brownish, watery scales were observed. Pantoea species have been previously described as causing leaf blight of onions in Georgia and Michigan in the USA and South Africa, Brazil, and Uruguay (Hattingh and Walters 1981; Gitaitis and Gay 1997; Edens et al. 2006; Tho et al. 2015; De Armas et al. 2022; Rosende et al. 2022). P. agglomerans was recently reported in Chile (Sepúlveda et al. 2023), but this is the first report of P. ananatis and P. eucalypti affecting onions in central Chile. This detection is an alert call for the onion’s growers and exporters in Chile for upcoming seasons, where conditions predisposing to disease may continue to occur. It is crucial to continue analyzing the factors that caused the appearance of this new disease in onions.