Secondarily estimated cure fraction and five-year recurrence-free conditional survival probabilities among patients undergoing surgical resection for hepatocellular carcinoma presenting with minor gross vascular invasion

Abstract

Abstract Background Surgical resection (SR) has been selectively applied in hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) presenting with minor gross vascular invasion (mGVI) which is defined when tumor invasion is confined to second-order portal branches or segmental branches of hepatic vein. However, little data of long-term outcomes are available for supporting the role of SR as a potentially curable therapeutic option for HCC presenting with mGVI. This study is aimed to estimate a statistical cure fraction and the improvement of recurrence-free conditional survival (RFCS) over time among patients undergoing SR for HCC presenting with mGVI. Methods The literature search was conducted focusing on previous studies that investigated the long-term survival rates of patients after SR for HCC presenting with mGVI. The reference cohort was extracted from a study including patients undergoing SR for HCC without vascular invasion. A non-mixture cure model was adopted to estimate the statistical cure fraction. The 5-year RFCS probabilities were also calculated. Results Three retrospective studies were secondarily analyzed. The probability of being statistically cured after SR for HCC presenting with mGVI was 7.3% (95% confidence interval, 4.4%–11.2%) in the mGVI group, lower than that of the reference cohort (hazard ratio, 1.81; 95% confidence interval, 1.59–2.05). The estimated 5-year RFCS probabilities improved with each additional year of survival. Moreover, 1 year after SR, the 5-year RFCS probabilities of patients with HCC presenting with mGVI was essentially the same as that of the reference cohort. Conclusions This study shows that a cure can be expected in around seven percent of patients undergoing SR for HCC presenting with mGVI. Furthermore, recurrence-free survival expectancy improves dramatically over time among those patients who do not have recurrence. Overall, these findings suggest that SR should be considered as a potentially curable treatment for patients with HCC presenting with mGVI.