Clinical complexity and impact of the ABC (Atrial fibrillation Better Care) pathway in patients with atrial fibrillation: a report from the ESC-EHRA EURObservational Research Programme in AF General Long-Term Registry
-
Published:2022-09-02
Issue:1
Volume:20
Page:
-
ISSN:1741-7015
-
Container-title:BMC Medicine
-
language:en
-
Short-container-title:BMC Med
Author:
Romiti Giulio Francesco, Proietti Marco, Vitolo Marco, Bonini Niccolò, Fawzy Ameenathul Mazaya, Ding Wern Yew, Fauchier Laurent, Marin Francisco, Nabauer Michael, Dan Gheorghe Andrei, Potpara Tatjana S., Boriani Giuseppe, Lip Gregory Y. H.ORCID, Tavazzi L., Maggioni A. P., Kalarus Z., Ferrari R., Shantsila A., Goda A., Mairesse G., Shalganov T., Antoniades L., Taborsky M., Riahi S., Muda P., García Bolao I., Piot O., Etsadashvili K., Simantirakis E. N., Haim M., Azhari A., Najafian J., Santini M., Mirrakhimov E., Kulzida K., Erglis A., Poposka L., Burg M. R., Crijns H., Erküner Ö., Atar D., Lenarczyk R., Oliveira M. Martins, Shah D., Serdechnaya E., Diker E., Lane D., Zëra E., Ekmekçiu U., Paparisto V., Tase M., Gjergo H., Dragoti J., Goda A., Ciutea M., Ahadi N., el Husseini Z., Raepers M., Leroy J., Haushan P., Jourdan A., Lepiece C., Desteghe L., Vijgen J., Koopman P., Van Genechten G., Heidbuchel H., Boussy T., De Coninck M., Van Eeckhoutte H., Bouckaert N., Friart A., Boreux J., Arend C., Evrard P., Stefan L., Hoffer E., Herzet J., Massoz M., Celentano C., Sprynger M., Pierard L., Melon P., Van Hauwaert B., Kuppens C., Faes D., Van Lier D., Van Dorpe A., Gerardy A., Deceuninck O., Xhaet O., Dormal F., Ballant E., Blommaert D., Yakova D., Hristov M., Yncheva T., Stancheva N., Tisheva S., Tokmakova M., Nikolov F., Gencheva D., Shalganov T., Kunev B., Stoyanov M., Marchov D., Gelev V., Traykov V., Kisheva A., Tsvyatkov H., Shtereva R., Bakalska-Georgieva S., Slavcheva S., Yotov Y., Kubíčková M., Joensen A. Marni, Gammelmark A., Rasmussen L. Hvilsted, Dinesen P., Riahi S., Venø S. Krogh, Sorensen B., Korsgaard A., Andersen K., Hellum C. Fragtrup, Svenningsen A., Nyvad O., Wiggers P., May O., Aarup A., Graversen B., Jensen L., Andersen M., Svejgaard M., Vester S., Hansen S., Lynggaard V., Ciudad M., Vettus R., Muda P., Maestre A., Castaño S., Cheggour S., Poulard J., Mouquet V., Leparrée S., Bouet J., Taieb J., Doucy A., Duquenne H., Furber A., Dupuis J., Rautureau J., Font M., Damiano P., Lacrimini M., Abalea J., Boismal S., Menez T., Mansourati J., Range G., Gorka H., Laure C., Vassalière C., Elbaz N., Lellouche N., Djouadi K., Roubille F., Dietz D., Davy J., Granier M., Winum P., Leperchois-Jacquey C., Kassim H., Marijon E., Le Heuzey J., Fedida J., Maupain C., Himbert C., Gandjbakhch E., Hidden-Lucet F., Duthoit G., Badenco N., Chastre T., Waintraub X., Oudihat M., Lacoste J., Stephan C., Bader H., Delarche N., Giry L., Arnaud D., Lopez C., Boury F., Brunello I., Lefèvre M., Mingam R., Haissaguerre M., Le Bidan M., Pavin D., Le Moal V., Leclercq C., Piot O., Beitar T., Martel I., Schmid A., Sadki N., Romeyer-Bouchard C., Da Costa A., Arnault I., Boyer M., Piat C., Lozance N., Nastevska S., Doneva A., Fortomaroska Milevska B., Sheshoski B., Petroska K., Taneska N., Bakrecheski N., Lazarovska K., Jovevska S., Ristovski V., Antovski A., Lazarova E., Kotlar I., Taleski J., Poposka L., Kedev S., Zlatanovik N., Jordanova S., Bajraktarova Proseva T., Doncovska S., Maisuradze D., Esakia A., Sagirashvili E., Lartsuliani K., Natelashvili N., Gumberidze N., Gvenetadze R., Etsadashvili K., Gotonelia N., Kuridze N., Papiashvili G., Menabde I., Glöggler S., Napp A., Lebherz C., Romero H., Schmitz K., Berger M., Zink M., Köster S., Sachse J., Vonderhagen E., Soiron G., Mischke K., Reith R., Schneider M., Rieker W., Boscher D., Taschareck A., Beer A., Oster D., Ritter O., Adamczewski J., Walter S., Frommhold A., Luckner E., Richter J., Schellner M., Landgraf S., Bartholome S., Naumann R., Schoeler J., Westermeier D., William F., Wilhelm K., Maerkl M., Oekinghaus R., Denart M., Kriete M., Tebbe U., Scheibner T., Gruber M., Gerlach A., Beckendorf C., Anneken L., Arnold M., Lengerer S., Bal Z., Uecker C., Förtsch H., Fechner S., Mages V., Martens E., Methe H., Schmidt T., Schaeffer B., Hoffmann B., Moser J., Heitmann K., Willems S., Willems S., Klaus C., Lange I., Durak M., Esen E., Mibach F., Mibach H., Utech A., Gabelmann M., Stumm R., Ländle V., Gartner C., Goerg C., Kaul N., Messer S., Burkhardt D., Sander C., Orthen R., Kaes S., Baumer A., Dodos F., Barth A., Schaeffer G., Gaertner J., Winkler J., Fahrig A., Aring J., Wenzel I., Steiner S., Kliesch A., Kratz E., Winter K., Schneider P., Haag A., Mutscher I., Bosch R., Taggeselle J., Meixner S., Schnabel A., Shamalla A., Hötz H., Korinth A., Rheinert C., Mehltretter G., Schön B., Schön N., Starflinger A., Englmann E., Baytok G., Laschinger T., Ritscher G., Gerth A., Dechering D., Eckardt L., Kuhlmann M., Proskynitopoulos N., Brunn J., Foth K., Axthelm C., Hohensee H., Eberhard K., Turbanisch S., Hassler N., Koestler A., Stenzel G., Kschiwan D., Schwefer M., Neiner S., Hettwer S., Haeussler-Schuchardt M., Degenhardt R., Sennhenn S., Steiner S., Brendel M., Stoehr A., Widjaja W., Loehndorf S., Logemann A., Hoskamp J., Grundt J., Block M., Ulrych R., Reithmeier A., Panagopoulos V., Martignani C., Bernucci D., Fantecchi E., Diemberger I., Ziacchi M., Biffi M., Cimaglia P., Frisoni J., Giannini I., Boni S., Fumagalli S., Pupo S., Di Chiara A., Mirone P., Fantecchi E., Pesce F., Zoccali C., Malavasi V. L., Mussagaliyeva A., Ahyt B., Salihova Z., Koshum-Bayeva K., Kerimkulova A., Bairamukova A., Mirrakhimov E., Lurina B., Zuzans R., Jegere S., Mintale I., Kupics K., Jubele K., Erglis A., Kalejs O., Vanhear K., Burg M., Cachia M., Abela E., Warwicker S., Tabone T., Xuereb R., Asanovic D., Drakalovic D., Vukmirovic M., Pavlovic N., Music L., Bulatovic N., Boskovic A., Uiterwaal H., Bijsterveld N., De Groot J., Neefs J., van den Berg N., Piersma F., Wilde A., Hagens V., Van Es J., Van Opstal J., Van Rennes B., Verheij H., Breukers W., Tjeerdsma G., Nijmeijer R., Wegink D., Binnema R., Said S., Erküner Ö., Philippens S., van Doorn W., Crijns H., Szili-Torok T., Bhagwandien R., Janse P., Muskens A., van Eck M., Gevers R., van der Ven N., Duygun A., Rahel B., Meeder J., Vold A., Holst Hansen C., Engset I., Atar D., Dyduch-Fejklowicz B., Koba E., Cichocka M., Sokal A., Kubicius A., Pruchniewicz E., Kowalik-Sztylc A., Czapla W., Mróz I., Kozlowski M., Pawlowski T., Tendera M., Winiarska-Filipek A., Fidyk A., Slowikowski A., Haberka M., Lachor-Broda M., Biedron M., Gasior Z., Kołodziej M., Janion M., Gorczyca-Michta I., Wozakowska-Kaplon B., Stasiak M., Jakubowski P., Ciurus T., Drozdz J., Simiera M., Zajac P., Wcislo T., Zycinski P., Kasprzak J., Olejnik A., Harc-Dyl E., Miarka J., Pasieka M., Ziemińska-Łuć M., Bujak W., Śliwiński A., Grech A., Morka J., Petrykowska K., Prasał M., Hordyński G., Feusette P., Lipski P., Wester A., Streb W., Romanek J., Woźniak P., Chlebuś M., Szafarz P., Stanik W., Zakrzewski M., Kaźmierczak J., Przybylska A., Skorek E., Błaszczyk H., Stępień M., Szabowski S., Krysiak W., Szymańska M., Karasiński J., Blicharz J., Skura M., Hałas K., Michalczyk L., Orski Z., Krzyżanowski K., Skrobowski A., Zieliński L., Tomaszewska-Kiecana M., Dłużniewski M., Kiliszek M., Peller M., Budnik M., Balsam P., Opolski G., Tymińska A., Ozierański K., Wancerz A., Borowiec A., Majos E., Dabrowski R., Szwed H., Musialik-Lydka A., Leopold-Jadczyk A., Jedrzejczyk-Patej E., Koziel M., Lenarczyk R., Mazurek M., Kalarus Z., Krzemien-Wolska K., Starosta P., Nowalany-Kozielska E., Orzechowska A., Szpot M., Staszel M., Almeida S., Pereira H., Brandão Alves L., Miranda R., Ribeiro L., Costa F., Morgado F., Carmo P., Galvao Santos P., Bernardo R., Adragão P., Ferreira da Silva G., Peres M., Alves M., Leal M., Cordeiro A., Magalhães P., Fontes P., Leão S., Delgado A., Costa A., Marmelo B., Rodrigues B., Moreira D., Santos J., Santos L., Terchet A., Darabantiu D., Mercea S., Turcin Halka V., Pop Moldovan A., Gabor A., Doka B., Catanescu G., Rus H., Oboroceanu L., Bobescu E., Popescu R., Dan A., Buzea A., Daha I., Dan G., Neuhoff I., Baluta M., Ploesteanu R., Dumitrache N., Vintila M., Daraban A., Japie C., Badila E., Tewelde H., Hostiuc M., Frunza S., Tintea E., Bartos D., Ciobanu A., Popescu I., Toma N., Gherghinescu C., Cretu D., Patrascu N., Stoicescu C., Udroiu C., Bicescu G., Vintila V., Vinereanu D., Cinteza M., Rimbas R., Grecu M., Cozma A., Boros F., Ille M., Tica O., Tor R., Corina A., Jeewooth A., Maria B., Georgiana C., Natalia C., Alin D., Dinu-Andrei D., Livia M., Daniela R., Larisa R., Umaar S., Tamara T., Popescu M. Ioachim, Nistor D., Sus I., Coborosanu O., Alina-Ramona N., Dan R., Petrescu L., Ionescu G., Popescu I., Vacarescu C., Goanta E., Mangea M., Ionac A., Mornos C., Cozma D., Pescariu S., Solodovnicova E., Soldatova I., Shutova J., Tjuleneva L., Zubova T., Uskov V., Obukhov D., Rusanova G., Soldatova I., Isakova N., Odinsova S., Arhipova T., Kazakevich E., Serdechnaya E., Zavyalova O., Novikova T., Riabaia I., Zhigalov S., Drozdova E., Luchkina I., Monogarova Y., Hegya D., Rodionova L., Rodionova L., Nevzorova V., Soldatova I., Lusanova O., Arandjelovic A., Toncev D., Milanov M., Sekularac N., Zdravkovic M., Hinic S., Dimkovic S., Acimovic T., Saric J., Polovina M., Vujisic-Tesic B., Nedeljkovic M., Zlatar M., Asanin M., Vasic V., Popovic Z., Djikic D., Sipic M., Peric V., Dejanovic B., Milosevic N., Stevanovic A., Andric A., Pencic B., Pavlovic-Kleut M., Celic V., Pavlovic M., Petrovic M., Vuleta M., Petrovic N., Simovic S., Savovic Z., Milanov S., Davidovic G., Iric-Cupic V., Simonovic D., Stojanovic M., Stojanovic S., Mitic V., Ilic V., Petrovic D., Deljanin Ilic M., Ilic S., Stoickov V., Markovic S., Kovacevic S., García Fernandez A., Perez Cabeza A., Anguita M., Tercedor Sanchez L., Mau E., Loayssa J., Ayarra M., Carpintero M., Roldán Rabadan I., Leal M., Ortega M. Gil, Tello Montoliu A., Orenes Piñero E., Manzano Fernández S., Marín F., Romero Aniorte A., Veliz Martínez A., Quintana Giner M., Ballesteros G., Palacio M., Alcalde O., García-Bolao I., Bertomeu Gonzalez V., Otero-Raviña F., García Seara J., Gonzalez Juanatey J., Dayal N., Maziarski P., Gentil-Baron P., Shah D., Koç M., Onrat E., Dural I. E., Yilmaz K., Özin B., Kurklu S. Tan, Atmaca Y., Canpolat U., Tokgozoglu L., Dolu A. K., Demirtas B., Sahin D., Ozcan Celebi O., Diker E., Gagirci G., Turk U. O., Ari H., Polat N., Toprak N., Sucu M., Akin Serdar O., Taha Alper A., Kepez A., Yuksel Y., Uzunselvi A., Yuksel S., Sahin M., Kayapinar O., Ozcan T., Kaya H., Yilmaz M. B., Kutlu M., Demir M., Gibbs C., Kaminskiene S., Bryce M., Skinner A., Belcher G., Hunt J., Stancombe L., Holbrook B., Peters C., Tettersell S., Shantsila A., Lane D., Senoo K., Russell K., Domingos P., Hussain S., Partridge J., Haynes R., Bahadur S., Brown R., McMahon S., McDonald J., Balachandran K., Singh R., Garg S., Desai H., Davies K., Goddard W., Galasko G., Rahman I., Chua Y., Payne O., Preston S., Brennan O., Pedley L., Whiteside C., Dickinson C., Brown J., Jones K., Benham L., Brady R., Buchanan L., Ashton A., Crowther H., Fairlamb H., Thornthwaite S., Relph C., McSkeane A., Poultney U., Kelsall N., Rice P., Wilson T., Wrigley M., Kaba R., Patel T., Young E., Law J., Runnett C., Thomas H., McKie H., Fuller J., Pick S., Sharp A., Hunt A., Thorpe K., Hardman C., Cusack E., Adams L., Hough M., Keenan S., Bowring A., Watts J., Zaman J., Goffin K., Nutt H., Beerachee Y., Featherstone J., Mills C., Pearson J., Stephenson L., Grant S., Wilson A., Hawksworth C., Alam I., Robinson M., Ryan S., Egdell R., Gibson E., Holland M., Leonard D., Mishra B., Ahmad S., Randall H., Hill J., Reid L., George M., McKinley S., Brockway L., Milligan W., Sobolewska J., Muir J., Tuckis L., Winstanley L., Jacob P., Kaye S., Morby L., Jan A., Sewell T., Boos C., Wadams B., Cope C., Jefferey P., Andrews N., Getty A., Suttling A., Turner C., Hudson K., Austin R., Howe S., Iqbal R., Gandhi N., Brophy K., Mirza P., Willard E., Collins S., Ndlovu N., Subkovas E., Karthikeyan V., Waggett L., Wood A., Bolger A., Stockport J., Evans L., Harman E., Starling J., Williams L., Saul V., Sinha M., Bell L., Tudgay S., Kemp S., Brown J., Frost L., Ingram T., Loughlin A., Adams C., Adams M., Hurford F., Owen C., Miller C., Donaldson D., Tivenan H., Button H., Nasser A., Jhagra O., Stidolph B., Brown C., Livingstone C., Duffy M., Madgwick P., Roberts P., Greenwood E., Fletcher L., Beveridge M., Earles S., McKenzie D., Beacock D., Dayer M., Seddon M., Greenwell D., Luxton F., Venn F., Mills H., Rewbury J., James K., Roberts K., Tonks L., Felmeden D., Taggu W., Summerhayes A., Hughes D., Sutton J., Felmeden L., Khan M., Walker E., Norris L., O’Donohoe L., Mozid A., Dymond H., Lloyd-Jones H., Saunders G., Simmons D., Coles D., Cotterill D., Beech S., Kidd S., Wrigley B., Petkar S., Smallwood A., Jones R., Radford E., Milgate S., Metherell S., Cottam V., Buckley C., Broadley A., Wood D., Allison J., Rennie K., Balian L., Howard L., Pippard L., Board S., Pitt-Kerby T.,
Abstract
Abstract
Background
Clinical complexity is increasingly prevalent among patients with atrial fibrillation (AF). The ‘Atrial fibrillation Better Care’ (ABC) pathway approach has been proposed to streamline a more holistic and integrated approach to AF care; however, there are limited data on its usefulness among clinically complex patients. We aim to determine the impact of ABC pathway in a contemporary cohort of clinically complex AF patients.
Methods
From the ESC-EHRA EORP-AF General Long-Term Registry, we analysed clinically complex AF patients, defined as the presence of frailty, multimorbidity and/or polypharmacy. A K-medoids cluster analysis was performed to identify different groups of clinical complexity. The impact of an ABC-adherent approach on major outcomes was analysed through Cox-regression analyses and delay of event (DoE) analyses.
Results
Among 9966 AF patients included, 8289 (83.1%) were clinically complex. Adherence to the ABC pathway in the clinically complex group reduced the risk of all-cause death (adjusted HR [aHR]: 0.72, 95%CI 0.58–0.91), major adverse cardiovascular events (MACEs; aHR: 0.68, 95%CI 0.52–0.87) and composite outcome (aHR: 0.70, 95%CI: 0.58–0.85). Adherence to the ABC pathway was associated with a significant reduction in the risk of death (aHR: 0.74, 95%CI 0.56–0.98) and composite outcome (aHR: 0.76, 95%CI 0.60–0.96) also in the high-complexity cluster; similar trends were observed for MACEs. In DoE analyses, an ABC-adherent approach resulted in significant gains in event-free survival for all the outcomes investigated in clinically complex patients. Based on absolute risk reduction at 1 year of follow-up, the number needed to treat for ABC pathway adherence was 24 for all-cause death, 31 for MACEs and 20 for the composite outcome.
Conclusions
An ABC-adherent approach reduces the risk of major outcomes in clinically complex AF patients. Ensuring adherence to the ABC pathway is essential to improve clinical outcomes among clinically complex AF patients.
Publisher
Springer Science and Business Media LLC
Reference37 articles.
1. Woolford SJ, Aggarwal P, Sheikh CJ, Patel HP. Frailty, multimorbidity and polypharmacy. Medicine (United Kingdom). 2021;49:166–72. 2. Gallagher C, Nyfort-Hansen K, Rowett D, Wong CX, Middeldorp ME, Mahajan R, et al. Polypharmacy and health outcomes in atrial fibrillation: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Open Heart. 2020;7:e001257. 3. Chen N, Alam AB, Lutsey PL, Maclehose RF, Claxton JS, Chen LY, et al. Polypharmacy, adverse outcomes, and treatment effectiveness in patients ≥75 with atrial fibrillation. J Am Heart Assoc. 2020;9:15089. 4. Jani BD, Nicholl BI, McQueenie R, Connelly DT, Hanlon P, Gallacher KI, et al. Multimorbidity and co-morbidity in atrial fibrillation and effects on survival: findings from UK Biobank cohort. Europace. 2018;20:f329–36. 5. Proietti M, Cesari M. Describing the relationship between atrial fibrillation and frailty: clinical implications and open research questions. Exp Gerontol. 2021;152:111455.
Cited by
35 articles.
订阅此论文施引文献
订阅此论文施引文献,注册后可以免费订阅5篇论文的施引文献,订阅后可以查看论文全部施引文献
|
|