The myth and truth of a comprehensive stroke scale

Abstract

Abstract Background and purpose The National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS) has been found to be biased toward the left hemispheric and motoric functions providing minimal assessment to the right hemispheric language and cognitive functions. The need to complement the role of the NIHSS is necessary in accurate and rapid assessment of AIS patients and better management. We hypothesized that combining the NIHSS with a quantitative analysis of Spoken Picture Description scale of Comprehensive Aphasia Test (SPD-CAT) could provide valuable data regarding side, site, and size of stroke. Subjects and methods Eighty-six AIS patients presented within 48 h of onset of stroke were enrolled from Stroke Units of Ain-Shams University Hospitals (ASUHS). Clinical Assessment with NIHSS and SPD-CAT were correlated with the radiological MRI Brain lesions of stroke regarding (site, side, size/volume and lesion volume percent to the whole brain volume “LV% WBV”). Results Total and subscale scores of NIHSS and SPD-CAT have a highly statistically significant correlation with the ischemic “LV% WBV.” Quantitative analysis (content units) of SPD-CAT may help in prediction of the lobar site of the stroke with higher significance in the tempro-parietal and brainstem regions. Right hemispheric strokes have clinically and statistically significant scores on SPD-CAT in comparison to NIHSS scores. Also, the left to right ratio of content units of information carrying words (ICWs) in SPD-CAT gives a significant difference between right and left hemispheric strokes. Recording and analysis time of SPD-CAT makes it easy and rapidly applicable in emergency room (ER) and stroke units. Conclusion Combining the quantitative analysis of NIHSS and SPD-CAT can better predict the side, size, and site of AIS within reasonable time table and without urgent MRI for AIS assessment and management.