Author:
Rickli Christina,Stoll Julia,Westermair Anna Lisa,Trachsel Manuel
Abstract
Abstract
Background
Psychiatrists face a major ethical challenge when deciding whether to make use of coercive measures in the treatment process of patients suffering from severe and persistent mental illness (SPMI). As India and Switzerland show major cultural, political and financial differences, it is hypothesized that attitudes towards coercive measures among Indian and Swiss psychiatrists will vary too. Exploring differences in attitudes between cultures strengthens the critical reflection on one’s own stances and in consequence, on our way of action. Especially when it comes to situations involving power imbalances between patients and health practitioners, self-reflection is essential to prevent ethically inappropriate behavior.
Methods
An online survey on aspects of care for patients with SPMI was sent to 3’056 members of the Indian Psychiatric Society between April and June 2020 and to 1’311 members of the Swiss Society for Psychiatry and Psychotherapy between February and March 2016. The respondents’ answers were compared. This article deals with the questionnaire’s items on autonomous decision making and the implementation of coercive measures in clinical practice. More precisely, participating psychiatrists were asked to rate the importance of patient’s autonomy in general and their willingness to apply coercive measures regarding two specific case vignettes depicting a patient with schizophrenia and one with depression. The statistical analysis, namely descriptive data analysis and calculation of arithmetic means, Shapiro Wilks tests and Mann-Whitney U tests, was carried out using IBM SPSS Statistics version 27.
Results
Answers were received from 206 psychiatrists in India and 457 psychiatrists in Switzerland. Indian participants tended to value autonomous decision making as slightly less important than Swiss participants (62.2% vs. 91%, p =.01). Regarding a case of severe and persistent depression, psychiatrists in the Indian group were on average more in favor of acting against the wishes of the patient (55% vs. 34.1%, p <.0001) as well as of accepting a temporary decrease in quality of life due to coercion (40% vs. 23%, p =.008). Answers concerning a case of schizophrenia revealed that Indian participants were more in favor of acting against the patient’s wishes than Swiss participants (39% vs. 37%, p =.007), whereas the comparison whether to accept a temporary decrease in quality of life regarding this case showed no significant difference (p =.328).
Conclusions
The significant difference in attitudes towards coercive measures among Indian compared to Swiss psychiatrists found in this study might arise from a predominantly more collectivist society in India compared to Switzerland. Moreover, differences in financial resources, the organization of the health care system, and the historical background might have an influence. Continuous and critical reflection on one’s own views and behavior is essential, especially if ethical principles and individual rights could be violated through a power imbalance, as in the case of coercive measures.
Publisher
Springer Science and Business Media LLC
Reference59 articles.
1. Ruggeri M, Leese M, Thornicroft G, Bisoffi G, Tansella M. Definition and prevalence of severe and persistent mental illness. Br J Psychiatry. 2000;177:149–55.
2. Zumstein N, Riese F. Defining severe and persistent Mental Illness-A pragmatic utility Concept Analysis. Front Psychiatry. 2020;11:648.
3. Hotzy F, Moetteli S, Theodoridou A, Schneeberger AR, Seifritz E, Hoff P, et al. Clinical course and prevalence of coercive measures: an observational study among involuntarily hospitalised psychiatric patients. Swiss Med Wkly. 2018;148:w14616.
4. Wissenschaften SAdM. Zwangsmassnahmen in Der Medizin. Schweizerische Akademie der Medizinischen Wissenschaften SAMW; 2015. [.
5. Di Francesco R, Drohé L, Kronenberg P, ANQ. Nationaler Verein für Qualitätsentwicklung in Spitälern und Kliniken, Bern; w hoch 2 GmbH, Bern (2023). Symptombelastung und Freiheitsbeschränkende Massnahmen stationäre Psychiatrie Erwachsene. Nationaler Vergleichsbericht 2022. 2023.