Affiliation:
1. 1 Department of Politics and Public Administration , University of Limerick , Ireland
Abstract
Abstract
The concept of a policy advisory system (PAS) is devised to study the diverse range of actors involved in the policy formulation process from a system level. An optimal PAS should be adaptable, autonomous and transparent, and should deliver substantive and timely advice. This article discusses factors influencing developments in Ireland’s PAS, including the broader trends of politicisation and externalisation. The findings are informed by interviews and a survey circulated to Irish civil servants who perform policy worker tasks and are engaged in providing advice to ministers. The research finds that new structural and institutional arrangements introduced to Ireland’s PAS have created a greater capacity for evidence-based advice in the internal PAS and a more contested space for policy advice. It also highlights that this has not fundamentally disturbed embedded characteristics of the Irish policymaking environment. Political demand pressures from ministers (both personal and electoral) can drive elements of politicisation within the civil service whereby policy advice is weighted or discarded based on ministerial preferences.
Subject
Economics, Econometrics and Finance (miscellaneous),Public Administration,Sociology and Political Science
Reference66 articles.
1. Boin, A., Brock, K., Craft, J., Halligan, J., ‘t Hart, P., Roy, J., ... & Turnbull, L. (2020). Beyond Covid 19: Five commentaries on expert knowledge, executive action, and accountability in governance and public administration. Canadian Public Administration, 63(3), 339–68.
2. Boyle, R., & O’Riordan, J. (2021). Policy analysis in the civil service. In J. Hogan & M. Murphy (Eds), Policy analysis in Ireland (pp. 107–22). Bristol University Press.
3. Comptroller and Auditor General. (2007). Special report 56 – Improving performance-public service case studies. www.audit.gov.ie
4. Connaughton B. (2010). Glorified gofers, policy experts or good generalists: A classification of the roles of the Irish ministerial adviser. Irish Political Studies, 25(3), 347–69.
5. Connaughton, B. (2012). Ministers and their departments: Inside the ‘black box’ of the public policy process. In E. O’Malley & M. MacCarthaigh (Eds), Governing Ireland: From cabinet government to delegated governance (pp. 61–87). Institute of Public Administration.