How Lingering Fusional Adaptation Influences the Bielschowsky Head Tilt Test in Superior Oblique Paresis

Abstract

Abstract Background The lack of a positive Bielschowsky head tilt test (BHTT) is commonly seen as an indicator that superior oblique paresis (SOP) is not present. This study investigated the influence of fusion on the BHTT in unilateral SOP. Patients/Methods and Material We analyzed vertical fusional vergence using our eye-tracking haploscope and the value of BHTT difference (BHTTD) in 11 patients who were diagnosed with congenital unilateral SOP and able to fuse. Results Patients used one of three different mechanisms of vertical vergence to achieve fusion. The three fusional mechanisms were associated with a significantly different BHTTD (p < 0.05). Seven of the eleven patients used vertical recti-mediated fusion and had a mean BHTTD ± SD of 21.7 ± 6.3 prism diopters (PD). Three of these patients whom we measured after a patch test for at least 30 min showed a decreased BHTTD (12.7 ± 3.8 PD). Three of the eleven patients used a mixed (oblique/rectus) fusional mechanism and had a mean BHTTD ± SD of 9.3 ± 8.6 PD. Of these patients, the one whom we measured after patching showed an increase of 11 PD in BHTTD. The remaining patient used oblique muscle-mediated fusion and had a BHTTD of only 3 PD that increased to 21 PD after patching. One explanation for this BHTT behavior in the latter patient involves lingering vergence adaptation of the “paretic” superior oblique muscle (SOM) and contralateral inferior oblique muscle, which makes these muscles more effective when activated, as is the case on ipsilateral head tilt (part of the ocular counter-roll mechanism), lessening the expected increase in hyperdeviation. Similarly, in our patients with mixed fusion, the vergence-adapted “paretic” SOM and contralateral superior rectus muscle are activated on ipsilateral and contralateral tilt, respectively, lessening the hyperdeviation in both directions. In the other seven patients, however, the vergence-adapted ipsilateral inferior rectus muscle and contralateral superior rectus muscle are activated on contralateral tilt, accentuating the BHTTD. Conclusion Depending upon the specific muscles used for vertical fusion, the BHTTD is decreased or increased. The presence of a large BHTTD points to lingering or persisting fusional tonus involving the vertical rectus muscles. The lack of a positive BHTT does not rule out the diagnosis of SOP, but rather may be caused by lingering or persevering fusional tonus involving the oblique muscles. Performing the BHTT after a patch test for a minimum of 30 minutes may be necessary to reveal the BHTTD, supporting the diagnosis of SOP.