Validation of radiographic quality of simulation software - ImaSim

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Virtual radiographic simulation has been found educationally effective for students to practice their clinical examinations remotely or online. A free available virtual simulator-ImaSim has received particular attention for radiographic science education because of its portability, free of charge and no constrain of location and physical facility. However, it lacks evidence to validate this virtual simulation software to faithfully reproduce radiographs comparable to that taken from a real X-ray machines to date. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate imaging quality of the virtual radiographs produced by the ImaSim. Thus, the deployment of this radiographic simulation software for teaching and experimental studying of radiography can be justified. METHODS: A real medical X-ray examination machine is employed to scan three standard QC phantoms to produce radiographs for comparing to the corresponding virtual radiographs generated by ImaSim software. The high and low range of radiographic contrast and comprehensive contrast-detail performance are considered to characterize the radiographic quality of the virtual simulation software. RESULTS: ImaSim software can generate radiographs with a contrast ranging from 30% to 0.8% and a spatial resolution as low as 0.6mm under the selected exposure setting condition. The characteristics of contrast and spatial resolution of virtual simulation generally agree with that of real medical X-ray examination machine. CONCLUSION: ImaSim software can be used to simulate a radiographic imaging process to generate radiographs with contrast and detail detectability comparable to those produced by a real X-ray imaging machine. Therefore, it can be adopted as a flexible educational tool for proof of concept and experimental design in radiography.