Morphometric Comparison of Endoscopic Endonasal Transpterygoid and Precaruncular Contralateral Medial Transorbital Approaches to Sphenoid Sinus Lateral Recess

Abstract

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: The endoscopic endonasal transpterygoid approach (TPA), minimally invasive compared with the sublabial transmaxillary and transcranial approaches, still accounts for morbidity in benign lateral recess of sphenoid sinus (LRSS) pathologies. Others have suggested an alternative route to the LRSS, the endoscopic contralateral medial transorbital approach (cMTO). However, no quantitative evidence exists to support the clinical application of this approach. This cadaveric study, in a controlled laboratory setting, provides a morphometric comparison of the TPA and cMTO for accessing the LRSS. The study also details the anatomy and technical nuances for optimizing the cMTO corridor. METHODS: Ten fresh preinjected human cadaveric specimens (20 sides) were dissected with neuronavigation, completing endoscopic cMTO and TPA on each side. Four parameters—working distance to lateral recess, surgical exposure area, angle of attack (AoA), and surgical freedom—were measured for each approach. Relevant osteological measurements in 10 dried human skulls were recorded. RESULTS: The mean distance from the superior margin of the lacrimal sac impression to the inferior margin of the trochlear fossa was 10.29 ± 1.13 mm, and that from the anterior ethmoidal artery foramina to the posterior lacrimal crest was 9.63 ± 1.23 mm. The mean exposure area around the LRSS was significantly higher in TPA (614.09 ± 40.38 mm2) than in cMTO (391.19 ± 59.01 mm2, P = .001). The mean AoA was 9.83° and 10.24° in the cMTO and TPA, respectively, in the craniocaudal direction (P = .529). In the horizontal plane, it was 9.29° and 10.76° (P = .012). There was no significant difference in surgical freedom between the cMTO and TPA (804.61 and 806.05 mm3, respectively; P = .993). CONCLUSION: Although comparatively limited exposure area, the cMTO approach has a similar AoA and surgical freedom as TPA and offers better visualization and ergonomic advantages. cMTO provides a feasible, less morbid, multiport technique for benign sphenoid sinus lateral recess pathologies.