Questioning the foundations of the gut microbiota and obesity

Abstract

The role of the gut microbiota in determining body fatness has been a prominent area of research and has received significant public attention. Based largely on animal studies, recent attempts to translate these findings into interventions in humans have not been successful. This review will outline the key mouse research that initiated this area of study, examine whether those results warranted the initial enthusiasm and progress into human studies, and examine whether later follow-up research supported earlier conclusions. It will look at whether the absence of a gut microbiota protects germ-free mice from obesity, whether microbiota can transfer obesity into germ-free mice, the evidence for the role of immune system activation as a causal mechanism linking the gut microbiota to body weight, and consider the evidence for effects of individual bacterial species. Finally, it will examine the outcomes of randomized controlled trials of microbiota transfer in human participants that have not shown effects on body weight. With a more critical reading, early studies did not show as large an effect as first appeared and later research, including human trials, has failed to support a role of the gut microbiota in shaping body weight. This article is part of a discussion meeting issue ‘Causes of obesity: theories, conjectures and evidence (Part II)’.