Abstract
In the past years, a new wave of progressive governments emerged in the Latin America region. Andrés Manuel López Obrador (Mexico, 2018), Alberto Fernández (Argentina, 2019), Pedro Castillo (Perú, 2021), and Gabriel Boric (Chile, 2022) present themselves as 'democratic' candidates in opposition to authoritarian and right-wing governments. In the eyes of many, this turn still represents hope, a way to confront oppressions and inequalities, strengthen democracy, promote development, and achieve social justice. Their contradictions or 'betrayals' are seen as errors, individual mishaps, or even as external intrusions; they are never understood as the result of a violent and oppressive process of 'othering' within the logic of accumulation rooted in the capitalist state. Mexico and Argentina exemplify this particular form of how capitalism operates in Latin America today. These countries illustrate how the production and reproduction of capital combine violence and extractivism, authoritarianism, and developmentalism via the state's use of 'progressive' rhetoric. Inspired by state derivation theorists, this chapter aims to answer the following questions: do progressive strategies differ from those of the far-right? Does this kind of government impact the form of the state differently? Or is it that both progressive and right-wing, are these two facets equally necessary to reproduce capitalist social relations?
Reference58 articles.
1. Álvarez Huwiler, Laura, and Alberto Bonnet (2018), “Ensayo y error. Un análisis marxista de las políticas públicas”, Revista Mexicana de Ciencias Políticas y Sociales, vol. 63, no. 233, pp. 169–92.
2. Bermúdez Peña, Claudia, Marisol Troya, Celina Vacca, and Gabriela Veronelli (2016), “Estado y colonialidad: Preguntas iniciales y primeros avances de investigación”, Estudios Sociales del Estado, vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 221–31.
3. Bloom, Peter (2016), Authoritarian Capitalism in the Age of Globalization, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.
4. Bonnet, Alberto (2007), “Estado y capital. Los debates sobre la derivación y la reformulación del Estado”, Estado y Marxismo. Un siglo y medio de debates, edited by Mabel Thwaites Rey, Buenos Aires: Prometeo Libros, pp. 269–97.
5. Bonnet, Alberto, and Adrián Piva (2017), “Prólogo”, Estado y capital. El debate alemán sobre la derivación del Estado, edited by Alberto Bonnet and Adrián Piva, Buenos Aires: Herramienta Ediciones, pp. 9–26.