Modeling uncertainty: the impact of noise in T cell differentiation

Abstract

BackgroundThe regulatory mechanisms guiding CD4 T cell differentiation are complex and are further influenced by intrinsic cell variability along with that of microenvironmental cues, such as cytokine and nutrient availability.ObjectiveThis study aims to expand our understanding of CD4 T cell differentiation by examining the influence of intrinsic noise on cell fate.MethodologyA model based on a complex regulatory network of early signaling events involved in CD4 T cell activation and differentiation was described in terms of a set of stochastic differential equation to assess the effect of noise intensity on differentiation efficiency to the Th1, Th2, Th17, Treg, and TFH effector phenotypes under defined cytokine and nutrient conditions.ResultsThe increase of noise intensity decreases differentiation efficiencies. In a microenvironment of Th1-inducing cytokines and optimal nutrient conditions, noise levels of 3%, 5% and 10% render Th1 differentiation efficiencies of 0.87, 0.76 and 0.62, respectively, underscoring the sensitivity of the network to random variations. Further increments of noise reveal that the network is relatively stable until noise levels of 20%, where the resulting cell phenotypes becomes heterogeneous. Notably, Treg differentiation showed the highest robustness to noise perturbations. A combined Th1-Th2 cytokine environment with optimal nutrient levels induces a dominant Th1 phenotype; however, removal of glutamine shifts the balance towards the Th2 phenotype at all noise levels, with an efficiency similar to that obtained under Th2-only cytokine conditions. Similarly, combinations of Th1/Treg and Treg/Th17-inducing cytokines along with the removal of either tryptophan or oxygen shift the dominant Th1 and Treg phenotypes towards Treg and Th17 respectively. Model results are consistent with differentiation efficiency patterns obtained under well-controlled experimental settings reported in the literature.ConclusionThe stochastic CD4 T cell mathematical model presented here demonstrates a noise-dependent modulation of T cell differentiation induced by cytokines and nutrient availability. Modeling results can be explained by the network topology, which assures that the system will arrive at stable states of cell functionality despite variable levels of biological intrinsic noise. Moreover, the model provides insights into the robustness of the T cell differentiation process.