Person references, change in footing, and agency positioning in psychotherapeutic conversations

Abstract

This study contributes to the research on agency positioning in psychotherapy by looking at how clients and therapists, when discussing the client's difficulties, made use of two specific conversational practices, i.e., different grammatical forms of person reference and changes in footing, and what the consequences of this were for how the clients were positioned in relation to their problematic experiences. A data corpus of the first sessions of nine psychotherapies at a university training clinic in Finland was utilized. The uses of person references and changes in footing in therapists' initiative turns, clients' responses, and therapists' third position (recipient) actions were examined. The analysis showed that in initiative turns therapists usually used the second-person singular, as an invitation for the client to respond from his/her personal point of view, thus ascribing active agency to the client. When telling their problematic experiences, clients typically used so-called zero-person constructions, presenting such experiences as common to people in general, thus lessening their agency and inviting the therapist to share their experiential position. In recipient actions, therapists could use a combination of zero and active person reference which served to communicate an empathic stance and an invitation to the client to take an agentic observer position. Almost exclusively, only therapists used changes in footing. This could happen rapidly within single utterances and serve to express affiliation with the client's emotional experience and to invite or challenge the client to take an observer position. The study supplemented the CA change model with the DA and DSA notions of changes in agency positions as core elements in therapy talk and showed how variations in person references and changes in footing had a decisive influence on how different types of turns functioned within the overall conversational structure of the psychotherapy institution.