How does navigating with Augmented Reality information affect drivers’ glance behaviour in terms of attention allocation?

Abstract

Drivers can benefit from Augmented Reality (AR) information especially in ambiguous navigation situations compared to conventional Head-up displays (HUD). AR information is correctly superimposed on the relevant objects in the environment and therefore directly related to the driving situation. Hence, it is assumed, that drivers no longer have to switch glances between the AR information and the environment (Kim & Dey, 2009). It has to be investigated whether switching glances between the presented navigation information and the environment can be reduced with AR information compared to HUD information. Furthermore, the question arises whether AR information might capture drivers’ attention and therefore distract from the traffic situation compared to a HUD as AR information is presented on the driver’s primary visual axis. The aim of the driving simulator study was to examine glance behaviour in terms of attention allocation while participants navigated in an ambiguous left turn situation with an oncoming car in an urban area (N = 58). Hence, drivers were faced with the decision to turn in front of it or let it pass. A conventional HUD and an AR display presented the navigation information to the driver. The drives differed in traffic complexity (low vs. high) to provide indications whether drivers adapt glance behaviour to altered environmental conditions. Besides the navigation task, drivers performed a non-driving-related task to raise drivers’ mental load while navigating. Results showed that with the AR display participants payed more attention to an oncoming car in the ambiguous left turn situation than with the HUD, which indicates that AR information was not distracting. Furthermore, participants switched glances significantly less between the AR navigation information and the environment, which indicates that with the AR display the driver did not have to map the virtual information onto the real driving situation. Independently of the display type 88% of the participants let the oncoming car pass the first time in this situation. Moreover, subjective data showed that drivers benefitted from AR information. The results of this study contribute to the investigation and development of AR user interfaces.