A Penalized Empirical Likelihood Approach for Estimating Population Sizes under the Negative Binomial Regression Model

Abstract

In capture–recapture experiments, the presence of overdispersion and heterogeneity necessitates the use of the negative binomial regression model for inferring population sizes. However, within this model, existing methods based on likelihood and ratio regression for estimating the dispersion parameter often face boundary and nonidentifiability issues. These problems can result in nonsensically large point estimates and unbounded upper limits of confidence intervals for the population size. We present a penalized empirical likelihood technique for solving these two problems by imposing a half-normal prior on the population size. Based on the proposed approach, a maximum penalized empirical likelihood estimator with asymptotic normality and a penalized empirical likelihood ratio statistic with asymptotic chi-square distribution are derived. To improve numerical performance, we present an effective expectation-maximization (EM) algorithm. In the M-step, optimization for the model parameters could be achieved by fitting a standard negative binomial regression model via the R basic function glm.nb(). This approach ensures the convergence and reliability of the numerical algorithm. Using simulations, we analyze several synthetic datasets to illustrate three advantages of our methods in finite-sample cases: complete mitigation of the boundary problem, more efficient maximum penalized empirical likelihood estimates, and more precise penalized empirical likelihood ratio interval estimates compared to the estimates obtained without penalty. These advantages are further demonstrated in a case study estimating the abundance of black bears (Ursus americanus) at the U.S. Army’s Fort Drum Military Installation in northern New York.