Comparison of East Asian Summer Monsoon Simulation between an Atmospheric Model and a Coupled Model: An Example from CAS-ESM

Abstract

In this study, the Chinese Academy of Sciences’ Earth System Model Version 2 (CAS-ESM2) and its atmospheric component were evaluated for the ability to simulate the East Asian summer monsoon (EASM), in terms of climatology and composites in El Niño decaying years (EN) and La Niña years (LN). The results show that the model can realistically simulate the El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) annual cycle, the interannual variation, the evolution process, and the prerequisites of ENSO, but the trend of developing and decaying is faster than that of the observations. With regard to the climatological mean state in the EASM, the coupled model run can largely improve the precipitation and 850 hPa wind simulated in the atmospheric model. Moreover, the coupled run can also reduce the mid-latitude bias in the atmospheric model simulation. Composite methods were then adopted to examine performance in different phases of the ENSO, from a mature winter to a decaying summer. The atmospheric model can well reproduce the Western North Pacific Anomalous Anticyclone (WNPAC)/Western North Pacific Anomalous Cyclone (WNPC) during EN/LN well, but the westerly/easterly anomalies and the associated precipitation anomalies over the equatorial Central Eastern Pacific are somewhat overestimated. Compared with the atmospheric model, these anomalies are all underestimated in the coupled model, which may be related to the ENSO-related SST bias appearing in the Eastern Indian Ocean. Due to the ENSO and ITCZ bias in the historical simulations, the simulated ENSO-related SST and the precipitation anomaly are too equator-trapped in comparison with the observations, and the cold tongue overly extends westward. This limits the ability of the model to simulate ENSO-related EASM variability. For the subseasonal simulations, though atmospheric model simulations can reproduce the westward extension of the Western Pacific subtropic high (WPSH) in EN decaying summers, the eastward retreat of the WPSH in LN is weak. The historical simulations show limited improvement, indicating that the subseasonal variation in the EASM is still a considerable challenge for current generation models.