Textile Physical Barriers: An Assessment of the Prison Effect as a Design Criterion to Increase the Porosity without Loss of Efficacy

Abstract

Insect-proof screens are a physical method of crop protection against pests whose use is widespread. The hole size must be optimized since too small holes give rise to poorly porous textiles that cause a significant reduction in the permeability of the textiles to air. A common design strategy is to use a rectangular-hole geometry with the aim of limiting the hole width to prevent insect entry and increasing the hole length to increase the hole surface. However, the validity of this approach has not been tested, and indications suggest that it may not be offering the expected results. The results obtained discredit this widely accepted design criterion since they show that, while the hole width is maintained, protective screens lose efficacy as the hole length increases at least in the range of values considered. It is not possible to find an explanation for these results by considering the hole geometry from a two-dimensional point of view. However, when considering the spatial arrangement of the threads, it is understood that the passage surface for the insects is larger than that considered in the orthogonal projection images and that as the hole length increases, the efficacy of the textiles decreases.