Renal Tumors with Oncocytic and Papillary Features: A Phenotypic and Genotypic Study

Abstract

The occurrence of kidney oncocytic lesions with an admixed papillary component is not unusual in routine pathology practice. These neoplasms with dual morphology are classically recognized as collision tumors with variable malignant potential. Using immunohistochemistry, we investigated fluorescent in situ hybridization and next generation sequencing of the genetic and phenotypic profiles in the two components of 11 kidney tumors with colliding oncocytic and papillary features. The oncocytic component was CD117 positive, CK7 negative, and AMACR negative; the papillary component was CK7 positive, AMACR positive, and CD117 negative in all cases. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) results were inconsistent. Next generation sequencing (NGS) analysis demonstrated that the mutations identified in the two tumor components were identical and displayed an allelic frequency of approximately 50%, strongly suspicious for genetic polymorphisms. The two oncocytic and papillary tumor counterparts shared the same genetic profile and did not harbor pathogenic mutations. Clinical confirmation of the biological benign features of these tumors is required. The term collision tumor is not suitable for these neoplasms, and we propose the term oncopapillary tumor for this histological entity.