Innovative Computational Techniques for Multi-Criteria Decision Making, in the Context of Cultural Heritage Structures’ Fire Protection: Theory

Abstract

The preservation of cultural heritage structures includes, among others, an efficient fire protection design process. This engineering design process frequently generates critical decision making issues related to conflicts that involve the buildings’ authenticity preservation, the implementation of special fire protection measures and addressing the particular needs of such structures. However, conventional approaches based on prescriptive regulations are often problematic in such cases; on the contrary, Performance-Based (PB) approaches could successfully deal with such structures to deliver designs that satisfy an acceptable fire safety level, and at the same time minimize the cost and any interventions on the building’s appearance, to the extent that authenticity is a key demand. Thus, in this study the upgrade of the fire safety level of cultural heritage structures is expressed as a Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) problem. Accordingly, the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is incorporated into a new fire protection Selection and Resource (S&R) allocation model, aiming to assess both fire safety and authenticity preservation levels with reference to the protection measures selected. Furthermore, in this study two different multi-criteria optimization approaches are applied to generate optimized solutions of the fire safety upgrading scheme. In this first part of the study, the theoretical basis of the proposed S&R allocation model that relies on a MCDM problem and how to deal with is discussed, while in the second part the implementation of the proposed model is presented for two real-world test cases. More specifically, in this study the theoretical part of the multi-objective and the multi-disciplinary problems (belonging to the MCDM type of problems) is provided with respect to the problems’ description and the methods adopted for solving the corresponding problems.