Equivalent Stress Intensity Factor: The Consequences of the Lack of a Unique Definition

Abstract

The concept of an equivalent stress intensity factor Keq is used in the study of fatigue crack growth in mixed-mode situations. A problem seldom discussed in the research literature are the consequences of the coexistence of several alternative definitions of mixed mode Keq, leading to rather different results associated with the alternative Keq definitions. This note highlights the problem, considering several Keq definitions hitherto not analyzed simultaneously. Values of Keq calculated according to several criteria were compared through the determination of Keq/KI over a wide range of values of KI/KII or KII/KI. In earlier work on Al alloy AA6082 T6, the fatigue crack path and growth rate were measured in 4-point bend specimens subjected to asymmetrical loading and in compact tension specimens modified with holes. The presentation of the fatigue crack growth data was made using a Paris law based on Keq. Important differences are found in the Paris laws, corresponding to the alternative definitions of Keq considered, and the requirements for candidate Keq definitions are discussed. A perspective for overcoming the shortcomings may consist in developing a data-driven modelling methodology, supported by material characterization and structure monitoring during its life cycle.