Exploring Optimal Biomarker Sources: A Comparative Analysis of Exosomes and Whole Plasma in Fasting and Non-Fasting Conditions for Liquid Biopsy Applications

Abstract

The study of liquid biopsy with plasma samples is being conducted to identify biomarkers for clinical use. Exosomes, containing nucleic acids and metabolites, have emerged as possible sources for biomarkers. To evaluate the effectiveness of exosomes over plasma, we analyzed the small non-coding RNAs (sncRNAs) and metabolites extracted from exosomes in comparison to those directly extracted from whole plasma under both fasting and non-fasting conditions. We found that sncRNA profiles were not affected by fasting in either exosome or plasma samples. Our results showed that exosomal sncRNAs were found to have more consistent profiles. The plasma miRNA profiles contained high concentrations of cell-derived miRNAs that were likely due to hemolysis. We determined that certain metabolites in whole plasma exhibited noteworthy concentration shifts in relation to fasting status, while others did not. Here, we propose that (1) fasting is not required for a liquid biopsy study that involves both sncRNA and metabolomic profiling, as long as metabolites that are not influenced by fasting status are selected, and (2) the utilization of exosomal RNAs promotes robust and consistent findings in plasma samples, mitigating the impact of batch effects derived from hemolysis. These findings advance the optimization of liquid biopsy methodologies for clinical applications.