Investigating the Effects of Different Sizes of Silicone Rubber Vacuum Extractors during the Course of Delivery on the Fetal Head: A Finite Element Analysis Study

Abstract

During certain clinical situations, some parturients require instruments for operative vaginal delivery, and various designs of vacuum extractors may affect the fetal head. To investigate the biomechanical effects of divergent sizes of silicone rubber vacuum extractors, we employed finite element analysis in this study. First, we constructed computer models for different vacuum extractor sizes (diameters: 40 mm, 50 mm, 60 mm, and 70 mm), flat surface, hemispherical ball, and fetal head shape. A hemispherical ball was the main design for the vacuum extractor model, and the material used for the vacuum extractor was silicone rubber. Next, the settings of 1 mm vacuum extractor displacement and vacuum cap pressure of 60 cmHg were applied. The main observation markers of this study were the respective von Mises stresses on the vacuum extractor and skull by the reaction force on the fixed end. The concluded results revealed that vacuum extractors with larger diameters lead to greater reaction force, stress, and strain on fetal heads. Therefore, this study’s biomechanical analytic consequences suggest that clinicians avoid selecting larger vacuum extractors during operative instrumental delivery so that fetal heads will experience less external force, deformation, and resultant complications. It could also provide a practical reference for obstetricians for instrumental vaginal delivery with the vacuum extractor made of silicone rubber.