Towards Topological Geospatial Conflation: An Optimized Node-Arc Conflation Model for Road Networks

Abstract

Geospatial data conflation is the process of identifying and merging the corresponding features in two datasets that represent the same objects in reality. Conflation is needed in a wide range of geospatial analyses, yet it is a difficult task, often considered too unreliable and costly due to various discrepancies between GIS data sources. This study addresses the reliability issue of computerized conflation by developing stronger optimization-based conflation models for matching two network datasets with minimum discrepancy. Conventional models match roads on a feature-by-feature basis. By comparison, we propose a new node-arc conflation model that simultaneously matches road-center lines and junctions in a topologically consistent manner. Enforcing this topological consistency increases the reliability of conflation and reduces false matches. Similar to the well-known rubber-sheeting method, our model allows for the use of network junctions as “control” points for matching network edges. Unlike rubber sheeting, the new model is automatic and matches all junctions (and edges) in one pass. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first optimized conflation model that can match nodes and edges in one model. Computational experiments using six road networks in Santa Barbara, CA, showed that the new model is selective and reduces false matches more than existing optimized conflation models. On average, it achieves a precision of 94.7% with over 81% recall and achieves a 99.4% precision when enhanced with string distances.