Projected Elevated [CO2] and Warming Result in Overestimation of SPAD-Based Rice Leaf Nitrogen Status for Nitrogen Management

Abstract

Nitrogen (N) has a unique place in agricultural systems with large requirements. To achieve optimal nitrogen management that meets the needs of agricultural systems without causing potential environmental risks, it is of great significance to increase N use efficiency (NUE) in agricultural systems. A chlorophyll meter, for example, the SPAD-502, can provide a simple, nondestructive, and quick method for monitoring leaf N status and NUE. However, the SPAD-based crop leaf’s N status varies greatly due to environmental factors such as CO2 concentration ([CO2]) or temperature variations. In this study, we conducted [CO2] (ambient and enriched up to 500 μmol moL1) and temperature (ambient and increased by 1.5~2.0 °C) controlled experiments from 2015 to 2017 and in 2020 in two Free-Air CO2 Enrichment (FACE) sites. Leaf characters (SPAD readings, chlorophyll a + b, N content, etc.) of seven rice cultivars were measured in this four year experiment. Here, we provide evidence that SPAD readings are significantly linearly correlated with rice leaf chlorophyll a + b content (chl a + b) and N content, while the relationships are profoundly affected by elevated [CO2] and warming. Under elevated [CO2] treatment (E), the relationship between chl a + b content and N content remains unchanged, but SPAD readings and chl a + b content show a significant difference to those under ambient (A) treatment, which distorts the SPAD-based N monitoring. Under warming (T), and combined elevated [CO2] and warming (ET) treatments, both of the relationships between SPAD and leaf a + b content and between leaf a + b content and N content show a significant difference to those under A treatment. To deal with this issue under the background of global climate change dominated by warming and elevated [CO2] in the future, we need to increase the SPAD reading’s threshold value by at least 5% to adjust for applying N fertilizer within the rice cropping system by mid-century.