Impact of Riparian Buffer Zone Design on Surface Water Quality at the Watershed Scale, a Case Study in the Jinghe Watershed in China

Abstract

This study was conducted to evaluate the impact of riparian buffer zones on water quality in the Jinghe watershed, China. To evaluate the effectiveness of riparian buffers in reducing sediments and nutrients in surface runoff, we employed two validated models: the agricultural non-point source pollution model (AnnAGNPS) and the riparian ecosystem management model (REMM). The AnnAGNPS was used to divide the catchment into homogeneous drainage areas and generate upland loadings for the REMM. The REMM model was then utilized to assess the impact of different riparian buffer designs on sediments and nutrient reduction in surface runoff. We tested five designs, including the recommended standard design by the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA). This design with 20 m herbaceous perennials next to the field (Zone 3), followed by a 20 m wide harvestable deciduous forest in the middle (Zone 2), and a 10 m wide non-harvestable deciduous forest adjacent to the river (Zone 1). We also evaluated alternative designs, such as removing Zone 3, removing Zone 2, and reducing the widths of the buffer zones further. For the entire Jinghe watershed, we calculated, compared, and analyzed the annual totals of water inflow, sediment yields, and dissolved nitrogen in surface runoff into and out of Zone 1, 2, and 3 for all the designs. The analysis indicated that the removal efficiency of sediments ranged from 85.7% to 90.8%, and the removal efficiency of dissolved nitrogen in surface runoff ranged from 85.4% to 91.9% for all the designs. It is also indicated that riparian buffer zones are highly effective in reducing sediments and nutrients in agricultural runoff, even with reduced buffer widths. This finding underscores the importance of implementing riparian buffer zones as a valuable approach in the agricultural intensive watershed with constraints for allocating for the creation of standard riparian buffers.