Adaptability Analysis of Sentinel−1A and ALOS/PALSAR−2 in Landslide Detection in the Qinling-Daba Mountains

Abstract

Due to the complex terrain and intense tectonic activity, and harsh climate in the Qinling-Daba Mountains, many landslides occur in the area. Most of these landslides are extremely active, posing a serious threat to the safety and property of local residents. As a mature deformation-monitoring technology, InSAR has been widely used in landslide detection, but the steep terrain and dense vegetation in the Qinling-Daba Mountains make detection challenging. Hence, it is important to choose suitable data sources and methods for landslide detection via InSAR in this area. This study was the first to collect ALOS/PALSAR−2 and Sentinel−1A images to detect landslides in the Qinling-Daba Mountains, applying a method combining IPTA and SBAS. In total, 88 landslides were detected and validated. The results show that the deformation-detection error rate of Sentinel−1A is 2% higher than that of ALOS/PALSAR−2 and that its landslide-recognition rate is 47.7% lower than that of ALOS/PALSAR−2. Upon comparing and analyzing the visibility, coherence, closed−loop residuals, and typical time series of landslide deformation from the two kinds of data, it was found that the extremely low quality of available Sentinel−1 A summer data is a major factor influencing that system’s performance. ALOS/PALSAR−2 is more likely to detect landslides in areas with high vegetation coverage, meeting more than 90% of the monitoring needs. It is thus highly suitable for landslide detection in the Qinling–Daba Mountains, where seasonality is significant. In this paper, for the first time, multiple data sources are compared in detail with regard to their utility in landslide detection in the Qinling–Daba Mountains. A large number of accuracy metrics are applied, and the results are analyzed. The study provides important scientific support for the selection of data sources for future landslide monitoring in the Qinling–Daba Mountain area and similar areas and for the selection of methods to evaluate the accuracy of InSAR monitoring.