A Comparison of the Tribological Properties of SiC Coatings Prepared via Atmospheric Plasma Spraying and Chemical Vapor Deposition for Carbon/Carbon Composites

Abstract

The microstructure, mechanical performance, and tribological properties of SiC ceramic coatings prepared via atmospheric plasma spraying (APS) and chemical vapor deposition (CVD) method were compared to provide good anti-wear protection for carbon/carbon composites. The surface morphology of the APS-SiC coating was characterized as having a porous structure, whilst the CVD-SiC coating presented with many pyramidal-shaped crystals constituting the surface. The APS-SiC coating consists of a dominating SiC phase and a small fraction of the Si phase, while the XRD pattern of the CVD-SiC coating mainly consists of the SiC phase. The dense crystalline microstructure of the CVD-SiC coating made it possess a higher hardness and Young’s modulus at 31.0 GPa and 275 GPa, respectively. The higher H/E and H3/E2 parameters of the CVD-SiC coating implied that it exhibited better plastic resistance, which is also beneficial for anti-wear properties. The scratch test reflected the critical loads of the spallation of the APS-SiC coating and CVD-SiC coating, which were evaluated to be 25.9 N and 36.4 N, respectively. In the tribological test, the friction coefficient of the APS-SiC coating showed obvious fluctuations at high load due to damage to the SiC coating. The wear mechanism of the APS-SiC coating was dominated by abrasive wear and fatigue wear, while CVD-SiC was mainly dominated by abrasive wear. The wear rate of the CVD-SiC coating was far below that of the APS-SiC coating, suggesting the better wear-resistance of the CVD-SiC coating.