Estimating Stem Diameter Distributions with Airborne Laser Scanning Metrics and Derived Canopy Surface Texture Metrics

Abstract

This study aimed to determine the optimal approach for estimating stem diameter distributions (SDD) from airborne laser scanning (ALS) data using point cloud metrics (Mals), a canopy height model (CHM) texture metrics (Mtex), and a combination thereof (Mcomb). We developed area-based models (i) to classify SDD modality and (ii) predict SDD function parameters, which we tested for 5 modelling techniques. Our results demonstrated little variability in the performance of SDD modality classification models (mean overall accuracy: 72%; SD: 2%). Our best SDD function parameter models were generally fitted with Mcomb, with R2 improvements up to 0.25. We found the variable Correlation, originating from Mtex, to be the most important predictor within Mcomb. Trends in the performance of the predictor groups were mostly consistent across the modelling techniques within each parameter. Using an Error Index (EI), we determined that differentiating modality prior to estimating SDD improved the accuracy of estimates for bimodal plots (~12% decrease in EI), which was trivially not the case for unimodal plots (<1% increase in EI). We concluded that (i) CHM texture metrics can be used to improve the estimate of SDD parameters and that (ii) differentiating for modality prior to estimating SSD is especially beneficial in stands with bimodal SDD.