The Evolution of Mineral Hardness Reveals Both Changing Parageneses and Preservational Bias in the Mineralogical Record

Abstract

A survey of the average Mohs hardness of minerals throughout Earth’s history reveals a significant and systematic decrease from >6 in presolar grains to ~5 for Archean lithologies to <4 for Phanerozoic minerals. Two primary factors contribute to this temporal decrease in the average Mohs hardness. First, selective losses of softer minerals throughout billions of years of near-surface processing lead to preservational biases in the mineral record. Second, changes in the processes of mineral formation play a significant role because more ancient refractory stellar phases and primary igneous minerals of the Hadean/Archean Eon are intrinsically harder than more recently weathered products, especially following the Paleoproterozoic Great Oxidation Event and the production of Phanerozoic biominerals. Additionally, anthropogenic sampling biases resulting from the selective exploration and curation of the mineralogical record may be superimposed on these two factors.