Functional Divergence in the Affinity and Stability of Non-Canonical Cysteines and Non-Canonical Disulfide Bonds: Insights from a VHH and VNAR Study

Abstract

Single-domain antibodies, including variable domains of the heavy chains of heavy chain-only antibodies (VHHs) from camelids and variable domains of immunoglobulin new antigen receptors (VNARs) from cartilaginous fish, show the therapeutic potential of targeting antigens in a cytosol reducing environment. A large proportion of single-domain antibodies contain non-canonical cysteines and corresponding non-canonical disulfide bonds situated on the protein surface, rendering them vulnerable to environmental factors. Research on non-canonical disulfide bonds has been limited, with a focus solely on VHHs and utilizing only cysteine mutations rather than the reducing agent treatment. In this study, we examined an anti-lysozyme VNAR and an anti-BC2-tag VHH, including their non-canonical disulfide bond reduced counterparts and non-canonical cysteine mutants. Both the affinity and stability of the VNARs and VHHs decreased in the non-canonical cysteine mutants, whereas the reduced-state samples exhibited decreased thermal stability, with their affinity remaining almost unchanged regardless of the presence of reducing agents. Molecular dynamics simulations suggested that the decrease in affinity of the mutants resulted from increased flexibility of the CDRs, the disappearance of non-canonical cysteine–antigen interactions, and the perturbation of other antigen-interacting residues caused by mutations. These findings highlight the significance of non-canonical cysteines for the affinity of single-domain antibodies and demonstrate that the mutation of non-canonical cysteines is not equivalent to the disruption of non-canonical disulfide bonds with a reducing agent when assessing the function of non-canonical disulfide bonds.